Top 5 Board Certified Personal Injury Specialists in Arizona (2026)
Key Takeaways
- All 5 firms feature attorneys verified as Board Certified Specialists in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death by the State Bar of Arizona (trust 10/10), the highest-authority credential in the dataset.
- Goldberg & Osborne's John Edwards Osborne has held Board Certification since 1991 — the longest tenure among the 5 — and is also recognized by Best Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication (trust 9/10).
- The Husband & Wife Law Team's Mark Breyer is both Board Certified (since 2005) and a National Trial Lawyers Top 100 member (trust 8/10), appearing in 6 independent sources — more than any other firm on this list.
- Hirsch & Lyon Accident Law offers 25% contingency fees per Expertise.com and has recovered over $100 million per Ranking Arizona 2025.
- Gage Mathers Law Group has recovered more than $275 million in settlements and verdicts according to Expertise.com.
Based on cross-referencing the Arizona State Bar Board Certified Specialists directory (trust 10/10) with 6 additional sources including Best Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), National Trial Lawyers Top 100 (trust 8/10), and Expertise.com, here are Arizona's top 5 personal injury firms with Board Certified attorneys — ranked by meta-score.
Top 5 Board Certified Personal Injury Specialists — Ranked
Goldberg & Osborne — John Edwards Osborne, Board Certified since 1991 (State Bar of Arizona). Also recognized by Best Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication. Ranked #1 in Ranking Arizona 2025. Meta-score: 88/100 across 4 sources.
The Husband & Wife Law Team (Breyer Law Offices) — Mark P. Breyer, Board Certified since 2005 (State Bar of Arizona). Also a National Trial Lawyers Top 100 member and Million Dollar Advocates Forum member. Listed by Lawyer Legion, an established directory. Meta-score: 85/100 across 6 sources — the most appearances of any firm on this list.
Hirsch & Lyon Accident Law PLLC — Jack H. Hirsch, Board Certified since 2017 (State Bar of Arizona). Hirsch & Lyon Accident Law has recovered over $100 million per Ranking Arizona 2025 and offers 25% contingency fees per Expertise.com. Meta-score: 82/100 across 5 sources.
Gage Mathers Law Group — Martin H. Mathers, Board Certified since 2009 (State Bar of Arizona). Gage Mathers Law Group has recovered more than $275 million in settlements and verdicts per Expertise.com. Also listed by Lawyer Legion. Meta-score: 77/100 across 4 sources.
Kelly Law Team — Peter C. Kelly, Board Certified since 2000 (State Bar of Arizona). Kelly Law Team is also recognized by Expertise.com and Ranking Arizona 2025. Meta-score: 76/100 across 4 sources.
What Arizona Board Certification Means
The State Bar of Arizona awards Board Certification in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death to attorneys who pass a specialty exam, demonstrate substantial experience, and meet ongoing peer review and continuing education requirements. Only approximately 93 attorneys statewide hold this credential. Board Certification is the only specialization designation officially recognized by the Arizona Supreme Court.
How Board Certified Firms Compare on Other Rankings
| Firm | Board Certified Since | Best Lawyers | National Trial Lawyers | Expertise.com | Total Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goldberg & Osborne | 1991 | ✓ | — | ✓ | 4 |
| The Husband & Wife Law Team | 2005 | — | ✓ | ✓ | 6 |
| Hirsch & Lyon Accident Law | 2017 | — | — | ✓ | 5 |
| Gage Mathers Law Group | 2009 | — | — | ✓ | 4 |
| Kelly Law Team | 2000 | — | — | ✓ | 4 |
Goldberg & Osborne is the only Board Certified firm also recognized by Best Lawyers (trust 9/10). The Husband & Wife Law Team is the only Board Certified firm also named to National Trial Lawyers Top 100 (trust 8/10). All 5 firms appear on Expertise.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Board Certified mean for a personal injury lawyer in Arizona?
Board Certification is a specialization credential awarded by the State Bar of Arizona and recognized by the Arizona Supreme Court. Only approximately 93 attorneys statewide hold this designation in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death, requiring a specialty exam, substantial case experience, and peer review.
Which Board Certified personal injury firm has the longest certification history in Arizona?
Goldberg & Osborne's John Edwards Osborne has held Board Certification since 1991 — over 35 years — per the State Bar of Arizona directory. Goldberg & Osborne is also recognized by Best Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication.
Which Board Certified firm appears in the most independent rankings?
The Husband & Wife Law Team appears in 6 independent sources, including the State Bar of Arizona, National Trial Lawyers Top 100, Expertise.com, and Lawyer Legion. Mark Breyer has been Board Certified since 2005.
Are there Board Certified personal injury firms in Arizona with over $100 million in recoveries?
Yes. Hirsch & Lyon Accident Law has recovered over $100 million per Ranking Arizona 2025, and Gage Mathers Law Group has recovered more than $275 million per Expertise.com. Both firms feature Board Certified attorneys.
Do Board Certified personal injury lawyers in Arizona charge different fees?
Fee structures vary by firm. Hirsch & Lyon Accident Law advertises a 25% contingency fee per Expertise.com, which is below the typical 33% industry standard in Arizona.