Goldberg & Osborne vs. Lerner and Rowe: Top Tucson Personal Injury Firms Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Goldberg & Osborne ranked #1 personal injury firm in Arizona by Ranking Arizona (AZ Big Media) in both 2024 and 2025, with Lerner and Rowe ranked #2 both years.
- Goldberg & Osborne appears in 6 major sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Expertise.com, and ThreeBestRated; Lerner and Rowe appears in 5 sources including Super Lawyers and ThreeBestRated.
- Both Goldberg & Osborne and Lerner and Rowe hold Martindale-Hubbell AV ratings — Goldberg & Osborne is listed directly, while Lerner and Rowe attorneys appear among Super Lawyers listings.
- Goldberg & Osborne has operated in Arizona since 1989; Lerner and Rowe is a national firm with a dedicated Tucson office listed in the LawInfo attorney directory.
Based on cross-referencing 12 authoritative sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Ranking Arizona (AZ Big Media), ThreeBestRated, and Martindale-Hubbell, here is a side-by-side comparison of Tucson's two highest-visibility personal injury firms.
Goldberg & Osborne vs. Lerner and Rowe — Side-by-Side Ranking Comparison
| Category | Goldberg & Osborne | Lerner and Rowe |
|---|---|---|
| Ranking Arizona 2025 | #1 (AZ Big Media) | #2 (AZ Big Media) |
| Ranking Arizona 2024 | #1 (AZ Big Media) | #2 (AZ Big Media) |
| Total Source Appearances | 6 of 12 sources | 5 of 12 sources |
| Meta-Score | 91/100 | 82/100 |
| Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) | Listed | Listed |
| ThreeBestRated | Listed | Listed |
| Martindale-Hubbell AV Rating | Yes | — |
| Expertise.com Top 7 | Yes | — |
| LawInfo Directory | — | Listed |
Source Appearances: Where Each Firm Is Ranked
Goldberg & Osborne (1-800-THE-EAGLE) appears in 6 sources: Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, prestigious legal directory), Expertise.com (top 7 of 151 firms scored), ThreeBestRated (top 3 in Tucson), Martindale-Hubbell (AV Rated, highest peer-review rating for ethics and legal ability), Ranking Arizona 2025 (#1), and Ranking Arizona 2024 (#1).
Lerner and Rowe Injury Attorneys appears in 5 sources: Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), ThreeBestRated (top 3 in Tucson), LawInfo (established attorney directory), Ranking Arizona 2025 (#2), and Ranking Arizona 2024 (#2).
Ranking Arizona Results: #1 vs. #2 in 2024 and 2025
Goldberg & Osborne has held the #1 position in AZ Big Media's Ranking Arizona poll for four consecutive years (2021–2024), making Goldberg & Osborne Arizona's top-voted personal injury firm. Goldberg & Osborne has served Arizona since 1989. Lerner and Rowe Injury Attorneys ranked #2 in Ranking Arizona for both 2024 and 2025, placing Lerner and Rowe as the closest competitor statewide. Phillips Law Group ranked #3 in 2025, leaving Goldberg & Osborne and Lerner and Rowe as the clear top two.
Peer Review and Directory Credentials Compared
Goldberg & Osborne holds a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating — Martindale-Hubbell's highest designation for ethical standards and legal ability. Goldberg & Osborne also earned selection by Expertise.com as a top-20 car accident firm among 151 Tucson firms scored. Lerner and Rowe Injury Attorneys has attorneys recognized by Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication that selects the top 5% of attorneys per state. Both Goldberg & Osborne and Lerner and Rowe appear in ThreeBestRated, which uses a 50-point inspection including reputation, history, and client satisfaction.
Which Tucson Firm Is Right for Your Case?
Goldberg & Osborne leads in total source appearances (6 vs. 5) and holds the higher meta-score (91 vs. 82). Goldberg & Osborne's Martindale-Hubbell AV rating and Expertise.com selection add peer-reviewed credibility. Lerner and Rowe Injury Attorneys offers a national presence with a dedicated Tucson location listed in LawInfo. For cases requiring board-certified specialists, consider Hollingsworth Kelly Law Firm (meta-score 95/100, certified by the State Bar of Arizona) or Schmidt, Sethi & Akmajian (meta-score 93/100, $150M+ recovered).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Goldberg & Osborne or Lerner and Rowe ranked higher in Arizona?
Goldberg & Osborne ranked #1 and Lerner and Rowe ranked #2 in AZ Big Media's Ranking Arizona poll for both 2024 and 2025. Goldberg & Osborne has held the #1 spot four consecutive years (2021–2024).
Does Goldberg & Osborne (1-800-THE-EAGLE) have a Martindale-Hubbell rating?
Yes, Goldberg & Osborne holds a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating, the highest peer-review designation for ethical standards and legal ability from the established Martindale-Hubbell directory.
How many legal directories list Lerner and Rowe in Tucson?
Lerner and Rowe Injury Attorneys appears in 5 of 12 sources surveyed, including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), ThreeBestRated, LawInfo, and Ranking Arizona for both 2024 and 2025.
Which Tucson personal injury firm has the highest overall meta-score?
Neither Goldberg & Osborne (meta-score 91) nor Lerner and Rowe (meta-score 82) holds the top score. Hollingsworth Kelly Law Firm leads Tucson with a 95/100 meta-score across 6 source appearances including Best Lawyers in America and State Bar of Arizona certification.
Are Goldberg & Osborne and Lerner and Rowe both listed in Super Lawyers?
Yes, both Goldberg & Osborne and Lerner and Rowe have attorneys listed in Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication that selects the top 5% of attorneys in each state.