CaseyGerry vs McClellan Law Firm: Top Personal Injury Lawyers in San Diego Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers and The McClellan Law Firm each appear in 7 of 17 sources surveyed, earning meta-scores of 96 and 95 respectively.
- Both firms share recognition from Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Martindale-Hubbell, ABOTA San Diego Chapter, and Consumer Attorneys of San Diego.
- CaseyGerry holds exclusive credentials from Forbes Advisor, Lawdragon 500, and the Daily Journal — McClellan holds exclusive credentials from U.S. News (Tier 1), Inner Circle of Advocates, and Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year.
- Craig McClellan is the only San Diego personal injury attorney admitted to the Inner Circle of Advocates (top 100 plaintiff lawyers nationally).
- CaseyGerry is the only plaintiffs firm in San Diego with five ABOTA member partners and five past-presidents of Consumer Attorneys of San Diego.
Based on cross-referencing 17 authoritative sources — including U.S. News Best Law Firms (trust 10/10), Best Lawyers in America (trust 10/10), Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), and Forbes Advisor (Forbes Media, trust 9/10) — here is how San Diego's two top-ranked personal injury firms compare.
CaseyGerry vs McClellan Law Firm Side-by-Side Rankings
| Category | CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers | The McClellan Law Firm |
|---|---|---|
| Meta-Score | 96/100 | 95/100 |
| Source Appearances | 7 of 17 | 7 of 17 |
| Super Lawyers Rank | #1 | #2 |
| U.S. News Tier | Not listed | Tier 1 |
| Inner Circle of Advocates | No | Yes (Craig McClellan) |
| Forbes Advisor | Yes | No |
| Lawdragon 500 | Yes (6 partners) | No |
| Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year | No | Yes (Craig McClellan, 2025) |
| ABOTA Members | 5 partners | 1 (Chapter President) |
| Founded | 1947 | — |
Shared Credentials: Where CaseyGerry and McClellan Both Rank
CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers and The McClellan Law Firm both appear in four shared sources. Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication, ranks CaseyGerry #1 and The McClellan Law Firm #2 in San Diego personal injury. Martindale-Hubbell, an established legal directory, names both firms "Top Ranked" with AV Preeminent ratings. The American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA) San Diego Chapter includes partners from both CaseyGerry and The McClellan Law Firm. Consumer Attorneys of San Diego (CASD) recognizes both firms — CaseyGerry has five past-presidents of CASD, while Craig McClellan of The McClellan Law Firm has won the Outstanding Trial Lawyer Award three times.
CaseyGerry Exclusive Credentials: Forbes Advisor, Lawdragon 500, Daily Journal
CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers holds three exclusive recognitions The McClellan Law Firm does not. Forbes Advisor (Forbes Media, trust 9/10) named CaseyGerry among the best personal injury lawyers in San Diego. Lawdragon 500 (trust 9/10) selected six CaseyGerry partners as Leading Plaintiff Consumer Lawyers nationally. The Daily Journal (trust 9/10) recognized David S. Casey Jr. of CaseyGerry as a Top Plaintiff Lawyer (2020, 2021) and named David S. Casey Jr. among the Top 100 Lawyers in California 11 times. CaseyGerry is also San Diego's oldest plaintiffs firm, founded in 1947.
McClellan Exclusive Credentials: U.S. News Tier 1, Inner Circle of Advocates
The McClellan Law Firm holds three exclusive recognitions CaseyGerry does not. U.S. News Best Law Firms (trust 10/10) awarded The McClellan Law Firm a Tier 1 ranking in Personal Injury Litigation – Plaintiffs in San Diego. The Inner Circle of Advocates (trust 10/10) admitted Craig McClellan as the first and only San Diego personal injury attorney — membership is limited to the top 100 plaintiff lawyers nationally. Best Lawyers in America (trust 10/10) named Craig McClellan Lawyer of the Year for Product Liability Litigation (2025). Craig McClellan of The McClellan Law Firm has been listed as a Super Lawyer every year since 2007 and received the most votes of any lawyer in 2019.
CaseyGerry vs McClellan: ABOTA and CASD Leadership Compared
In professional legal organizations, CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers and The McClellan Law Firm diverge on breadth vs. depth. CaseyGerry has five ABOTA member partners — the only plaintiffs firm in San Diego with that many ABOTA members. Craig McClellan of The McClellan Law Firm served as ABOTA San Diego Chapter President. At CASD, CaseyGerry has produced five past-presidents and multiple Trial Lawyer of the Year recipients. Craig McClellan of The McClellan Law Firm has won CASD's Outstanding Trial Lawyer Award three times.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which firm ranks higher on Super Lawyers — CaseyGerry or McClellan?
CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers ranks #1 and The McClellan Law Firm ranks #2 on Super Lawyers San Diego 2025-2026, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication. Craig McClellan has been listed as a Super Lawyer every year since 2007.
Does CaseyGerry or McClellan have better national recognitions?
Both firms hold elite national credentials. CaseyGerry has six partners on the Lawdragon 500 and Forbes Advisor recognition. The McClellan Law Firm's Craig McClellan is the only San Diego personal injury attorney in the Inner Circle of Advocates (top 100 plaintiff lawyers nationally) and was named Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year 2025.
Which firm has higher-authority source rankings — CaseyGerry or McClellan?
The McClellan Law Firm holds two trust-10/10 recognitions (U.S. News Tier 1, Inner Circle of Advocates, Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year). CaseyGerry holds three trust-9/10 recognitions (Forbes Advisor, Lawdragon 500, Daily Journal) plus trust-8/10 from Martindale-Hubbell.
Are CaseyGerry and McClellan both members of ABOTA in San Diego?
Yes. CaseyGerry Trial Lawyers has five ABOTA member partners — the most of any plaintiffs firm in San Diego. Craig McClellan of The McClellan Law Firm is an ABOTA member and served as San Diego Chapter President.
How were CaseyGerry and McClellan compared in this article?
Rankings were aggregated from 17 sources using a weighted meta-score: source appearances (40%), average ranking position (30%), source authority (20%), and major publication credentials (10%). CaseyGerry scored 96/100 and The McClellan Law Firm scored 95/100.