Pratcher Krayer LLC Review: Personal Injury Lawyers in Wilmington (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Pratcher Krayer LLC scored 91/100 in MetaScore rankings, appearing in 4 of 10 authoritative legal directories surveyed for Wilmington personal injury firms.
- Samuel Pratcher III earned National Trial Lawyers Top 100 recognition for Delaware, a designation held by only 2 Delaware attorneys in the 2026 cycle.
- Nicholas M. Krayer was named to the NAOPIA Delaware Top 10 personal injury attorneys list.
- Both partners have been consecutively selected as Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) from 2021 through 2026.
- Pratcher Krayer LLC ranks #2 overall among 26 Wilmington personal injury firms evaluated, behind only Doroshow, Pasquale, Krawitz & Bhaya (92/100).
Based on cross-referencing 10 authoritative sources — including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), The National Trial Lawyers (trust 8/10), NAOPIA (trust 7/10), and Delaware Today Top Lawyers — Pratcher Krayer LLC ranks #2 among 26 Wilmington personal injury firms with a 91/100 MetaScore.
Pratcher Krayer LLC: Rankings Overview
Pratcher Krayer LLC appeared in 4 of 10 directories surveyed, placing the firm among the top tier of Wilmington personal injury practices:
- Super Lawyers 2021–2026 — Both Samuel Pratcher III and Nicholas M. Krayer selected consecutively for 6 years (Super Lawyers, Thomson Reuters)
- National Trial Lawyers Top 100 — Samuel Pratcher III recognized as a Top 100 trial lawyer for Delaware (National Trial Lawyers)
- NAOPIA Delaware Top 10 — Nicholas M. Krayer named to the Top 10 personal injury attorneys list (NAOPIA)
- Delaware Today Top Lawyers 2024 & 2025 — Both partners selected as Top Attorneys (Delaware Today)
Source-by-Source Breakdown for Pratcher Krayer LLC
Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10): Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication, uses a patented multiphase selection process including peer nominations, independent research, and peer evaluation. Pratcher Krayer LLC's 6-year consecutive selection (2021–2026) places both partners in the top 5% of Delaware attorneys.
National Trial Lawyers Top 100 (trust 8/10): Only 2 Delaware attorneys earned National Trial Lawyers Top 100 recognition in the current cycle — Samuel Pratcher III is one of them. The other is Robert Leoni of Shelsby & Leoni P.A. This established professional organization selects members through peer nominations and third-party research.
NAOPIA Delaware Top 10 (trust 7/10): The National Academy of Personal Injury Attorneys named Nicholas M. Krayer to its Delaware Top 10 list, an established directory that evaluates attorneys based on experience, case results, and peer recognition.
Delaware Today Top Lawyers (trust 4/10): Delaware Today Magazine, a regional review aggregator, selected both Pratcher Krayer LLC partners as Top Attorneys for 2024 and 2025.
Key Attorneys: Samuel Pratcher III and Nicholas M. Krayer
Samuel Pratcher III — Super Lawyers honoree 2021–2026 (Thomson Reuters), National Trial Lawyers Top 100 member for Delaware, and Delaware Today Top Attorney 2024–2025. Samuel Pratcher III is one of only 2 Delaware personal injury attorneys holding National Trial Lawyers Top 100 status.
Nicholas M. Krayer — Super Lawyers honoree 2021–2026 (Thomson Reuters), NAOPIA Delaware Top 10 personal injury attorney, and Delaware Today Top Attorney 2024–2025. Nicholas M. Krayer's NAOPIA Top 10 ranking places Pratcher Krayer LLC alongside firms like Schwartz & Schwartz (#1 NAOPIA, MetaScore 90/100) and Dalton & Associates (#7 NAOPIA, MetaScore 88/100).
How Pratcher Krayer LLC Compares to Other Wilmington Firms
| Firm | MetaScore | Sources | Notable Recognition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Doroshow, Pasquale, Krawitz & Bhaya | 92/100 | 4 | Super Lawyers, Expertise.com, Delaware Today |
| Pratcher Krayer LLC | 91/100 | 4 | National Trial Lawyers Top 100, Super Lawyers 6 consecutive years |
| Schwartz & Schwartz | 90/100 | 5 | NAOPIA #1 Delaware, Super Lawyers |
| Dalton & Associates | 88/100 | 4 | NAOPIA #7, Super Lawyers |
| Shelsby & Leoni P.A. | 75/100 | 3 | National Trial Lawyers Top 100, NAOPIA #6 |
Pratcher Krayer LLC is the only firm besides Shelsby & Leoni P.A. to hold National Trial Lawyers Top 100 recognition in Delaware. Pratcher Krayer LLC's 6-year Super Lawyers streak matches or exceeds streaks held by larger firms like Schwartz & Schwartz and Doroshow, Pasquale, Krawitz & Bhaya.
For a full comparison of Wilmington's top-ranked firms, see Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Wilmington, Delaware (2026) and Doroshow Pasquale vs. Pratcher Krayer vs. Schwartz & Schwartz.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Pratcher Krayer LLC's overall ranking among Wilmington personal injury firms?
Pratcher Krayer LLC ranks #2 of 26 firms with a 91/100 MetaScore, based on appearances in Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), National Trial Lawyers Top 100, NAOPIA Top 10, and Delaware Today Top Lawyers. Only Doroshow, Pasquale, Krawitz & Bhaya scored higher at 92/100.
Is Samuel Pratcher III a Top 100 trial lawyer?
Yes. Samuel Pratcher III holds National Trial Lawyers Top 100 recognition for Delaware — one of only 2 Delaware personal injury attorneys with this designation (the other being Robert Leoni of Shelsby & Leoni P.A.).
How long has Pratcher Krayer LLC been recognized by Super Lawyers?
Both partners — Samuel Pratcher III and Nicholas M. Krayer — have been consecutively selected as Super Lawyers by Thomson Reuters from 2021 through 2026, a 6-year streak placing them in the top 5% of Delaware attorneys.
How does Pratcher Krayer LLC compare to Schwartz & Schwartz?
Pratcher Krayer LLC (MetaScore 91/100) outranks Schwartz & Schwartz (90/100) by 1 point. Schwartz & Schwartz holds NAOPIA's #1 Delaware ranking, while Pratcher Krayer LLC holds the rarer National Trial Lawyers Top 100 designation.
What sources were used to evaluate Pratcher Krayer LLC?
Rankings aggregate data from 10 sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), U.S. News Best Law Firms, National Trial Lawyers Top 100, NAOPIA Top 10, Expertise.com, Avvo, and Delaware Today Top Lawyers, weighted by source appearances (40%), ranking position (30%), and source authority (20%).