Wilson Kehoe Winingham vs. Keller & Keller: Top Indianapolis Injury Firms Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranks #1 overall (87.5 meta-score) with appearances in all 5 sources including #1 rankings from Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and U.S. News Best Law Firms.
- Keller & Keller ranks #2 overall (85.2 meta-score) with 4 source appearances including a #1 ranking from Expertise.com (2026) and #2 from U.S. News Best Law Firms.
- Both firms hold identical 4.5-star Yelp ratings, with Keller & Keller ranked #2 and Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranked #3 on Yelp's 2025 list.
- Wilson Kehoe Winingham covers medical malpractice and wrongful death in addition to personal injury, while Keller & Keller focuses on personal injury and auto accidents.
- Wilson Kehoe Winingham appears in 5 of 5 sources surveyed; Keller & Keller appears in 4 of 5 (absent from Justia's directory).
Based on cross-referencing 5 authoritative sources — including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), U.S. News Best Law Firms (trust 9/10), Expertise.com (2026), Yelp (2025), and Justia — Wilson Kehoe Winingham and Keller & Keller are the two highest-ranked personal injury firms in Indianapolis.
Wilson Kehoe Winingham vs. Keller & Keller: Rankings at a Glance
| Source | Wilson Kehoe Winingham | Keller & Keller |
|---|---|---|
| Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025) | #1 | #3 |
| U.S. News Best Law Firms (2025) | #1 (Tier 1) | #2 |
| Expertise.com (2026) | #2 | #1 |
| Yelp (2025) | #3 (4.5 stars) | #2 (4.5 stars) |
| Justia | Listed | Not listed |
| Meta-Score | 87.5/100 | 85.2/100 |
| Source Appearances | 5 of 5 | 4 of 5 |
Wilson Kehoe Winingham leads in the two most prestigious sources — Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication, and U.S. News Best Law Firms. Keller & Keller leads in Expertise.com, a review aggregator that evaluates reputation, credibility, and professionalism.
Source-by-Source Comparison
- Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025) — Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranked #1 with multiple Super Lawyers selections. Keller & Keller ranked #3 with multiple attorneys recognized.
- U.S. News Best Law Firms (2025) — Wilson Kehoe Winingham earned a Tier 1 ranking (#1) for Personal Injury Litigation – Plaintiffs. Keller & Keller ranked #2.
- Expertise.com (2026) — Keller & Keller ranked #1 based on expertise in personal injury cases. Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranked #2 based on reputation, credibility, and experience.
- Yelp (2025) — Keller & Keller ranked #2 with 4.5 stars. Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranked #3 with 4.5 stars. Both firms have strong client satisfaction.
- Justia — Wilson Kehoe Winingham is listed as a featured Indiana personal injury firm. Keller & Keller does not appear in Justia's directory.
Practice Area Differences
Wilson Kehoe Winingham covers personal injury, medical malpractice, and wrongful death — listed under all three categories by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025). Wilson Kehoe Winingham also handles car accidents and truck accidents per Expertise.com (2026).
Keller & Keller focuses on personal injury and auto accidents, as categorized by both Super Lawyers (2025) and Expertise.com (2026). Keller & Keller does not appear in medical malpractice or wrongful death categories in any source surveyed.
Client Reviews: Yelp Ratings Compared
Both firms earned 4.5-star ratings on Yelp (2025). Keller & Keller edges ahead at #2 vs. Wilson Kehoe Winingham at #3 in Yelp's ranked results. Both firms outperform most competitors — only Hurst Limontes LLC (#1 on Yelp, 5.0 stars) ranks higher on Yelp's 2025 list.
Which Firm Is Right for Your Case?
- Medical malpractice or wrongful death cases: Wilson Kehoe Winingham is the stronger choice — Wilson Kehoe Winingham is listed under these categories by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters). Keller & Keller is not listed under either.
- Auto accident cases: Both firms are strong. Keller & Keller ranked #1 by Expertise.com (2026) for personal injury with auto accident focus. Wilson Kehoe Winingham covers car and truck accidents per the same source.
- Overall prestige: Wilson Kehoe Winingham holds #1 rankings from the two highest-authority sources (Super Lawyers and U.S. News, both trust 9/10).
Frequently Asked Questions
Which firm ranks higher overall — Wilson Kehoe Winingham or Keller & Keller?
Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranks #1 overall with an 87.5 meta-score across 5 sources, including #1 rankings from Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and U.S. News Best Law Firms. Keller & Keller ranks #2 with an 85.2 meta-score across 4 sources.
Does Keller & Keller outrank Wilson Kehoe Winingham on any source?
Yes. Keller & Keller ranks #1 on Expertise.com (2026) and #2 on Yelp (2025), beating Wilson Kehoe Winingham's #2 and #3 rankings on those same sources.
Which firm handles medical malpractice cases?
Wilson Kehoe Winingham is listed under medical malpractice and wrongful death by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025). Keller & Keller does not appear under medical malpractice categories in any of the 5 sources surveyed.
How do Wilson Kehoe Winingham and Keller & Keller compare on Yelp?
Both firms hold 4.5-star ratings on Yelp (2025). Keller & Keller ranks #2 and Wilson Kehoe Winingham ranks #3 — both behind Hurst Limontes LLC at #1 with 5.0 stars.
How many sources list each firm?
Wilson Kehoe Winingham appears in all 5 sources surveyed (Super Lawyers, U.S. News, Expertise.com, Yelp, and Justia). Keller & Keller appears in 4 of 5, absent from Justia's directory.