Best-Reviewed Personal Injury Lawyers in Louisville, Kentucky (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Winton & Hiestand Law Group leads with a perfect 5.0 stars across 362 Google reviews on TopInjuryLawyersList (2025)
- The Poppe Law Firm's Hans Poppe holds a 10.0 Superb Avvo rating — the platform's highest possible score
- Dolt, Thompson, Shepherd, Conway & Stanton is the only Louisville firm ranked #1 by both ThreeBestRated and Expertise.com
- Sam Aguiar Injury Lawyers won the 2025 Courier Journal Community Choice Award for Best Personal Injury Attorney in Louisville
- Seven Louisville firms carry 4.9- or 5.0-star ratings with over 100 Google reviews each on TopInjuryLawyersList
Based on cross-referencing client review data from TopInjuryLawyersList (Google review scores/counts), Avvo (a Martindale-Hubbell directory), ThreeBestRated, and Expertise.com, here are Louisville's best-reviewed personal injury lawyers.
Highest-Rated Personal Injury Lawyers in Louisville by Client Reviews
- Winton & Hiestand Law Group PLLC — 5.0 stars, 362 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); ranked #1 by Rviewo (2026); A+ BBB rating; featured in Forbes and Louisville Business First Best Places to Work 2024
- Stein Whatley Astorino PLLC — 5.0 stars, 220 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); Rising Stars recognition by Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication
- Louisville Injury Law Firm — 5.0 stars, 115 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); also ranked top 10 by Rviewo (2026)
- Sam Aguiar Injury Lawyers — 4.9 stars, 761 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); winner of Courier Journal 2025 Community Choice Award for Best Personal Injury Attorney; Forbes 2025 Best-In-State Lawyer
- Kaufman & Stigger PLLC — 4.9 stars, 770 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); Avvo Superb rating; over 100 years combined experience
- Isaacs & Isaacs Personal Injury Lawyers — 4.9 stars, 289 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); over $2 billion recovered; National Trial Lawyers Top 100 member
- T.J. Smith, Attorney at Law — 4.9 stars, 249 reviews (TopInjuryLawyersList, 2025); Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum; over $250 million recovered
Avvo Superb-Rated Louisville Personal Injury Attorneys
Avvo, an established Martindale-Hubbell directory, rates attorneys on a 1–10 scale based on experience, industry recognition, and professional conduct.
- The Poppe Law Firm — Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb (Avvo); Hans Poppe named ABOTA 2021 Plaintiff Trial Lawyer of the Year; U.S. News & Best Lawyers Tier 1 firm (2026)
- Cooper & Friedman Attorneys at Law — All partners are Million Dollar Advocates Forum and Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum members (Avvo); $6.3 million jury verdict (Expertise.com, 2025)
- DeCamillis & Mattingly PLLC — Over $100 million won for clients (Avvo); Robert Mattingly is National Trial Lawyers Top 100 member; Amanda Hartley named Louisville Top Lawyer
ThreeBestRated and Expertise.com Top Picks
ThreeBestRated, a review aggregator using a 50-point inspection, selected three Louisville firms:
- Dolt, Thompson, Shepherd, Conway & Stanton PSC — #1 on ThreeBestRated; also #1 on Expertise.com (2025); U.S. News Tier 1 (2026); Tyler Thompson is Inner Circle of Advocates member (limited to top 100 plaintiff lawyers in the U.S.)
- Grossman Green PLLC — #2 on ThreeBestRated; U.S. News & Best Lawyers recognized (2026); Super Lawyers recognition (2026)
- Dettman Law — Selected by Expertise.com (2025); Brian Dettman tried 57 cases through verdict (Rviewo, 2026); top-rated on Avvo
Review Counts and Ratings Compared
| Firm | Stars | Reviews | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kaufman & Stigger PLLC | 4.9 | 770 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| Sam Aguiar Injury Lawyers | 4.9 | 761 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| Winton & Hiestand Law Group | 5.0 | 362 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| Isaacs & Isaacs | 4.9 | 289 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| T.J. Smith, Attorney at Law | 4.9 | 249 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| Stein Whatley Astorino PLLC | 5.0 | 220 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| Justice Law Office | 4.9 | 217 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
| Dixie Law Group PSC | 4.8 | 196 | TopInjuryLawyersList 2025 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Louisville personal injury lawyer has the most client reviews?
Kaufman & Stigger PLLC leads with 770 Google reviews at 4.9 stars, followed closely by Sam Aguiar Injury Lawyers with 761 reviews at 4.9 stars, both per TopInjuryLawyersList (2025).
Which Louisville personal injury attorney has the highest Avvo rating?
Hans Poppe of The Poppe Law Firm holds a 10.0 Superb Avvo rating, the platform's maximum score. The Poppe Law Firm is also a U.S. News & Best Lawyers Tier 1 firm for personal injury litigation (2026).
What Louisville personal injury firms are selected by ThreeBestRated?
ThreeBestRated's 2026 selections are Dolt, Thompson, Shepherd, Conway & Stanton PSC (#1), Grossman Green PLLC (#2), and a third Louisville firm. Dolt Thompson also holds a #1 ranking from Expertise.com (2025).
Which Louisville personal injury lawyer has a perfect 5.0-star rating?
Winton & Hiestand Law Group (5.0 stars, 362 reviews), Stein Whatley Astorino PLLC (5.0 stars, 220 reviews), and Louisville Injury Law Firm (5.0 stars, 115 reviews) all hold perfect ratings on TopInjuryLawyersList (2025).
Has any Louisville personal injury lawyer won a community choice award?
Sam Aguiar Injury Lawyers won the Courier Journal 2025 Community Choice Award for Best Personal Injury Attorney in Louisville. Sam Aguiar was also named a Forbes 2025 Best-In-State Lawyer for Kentucky.