Best Lawyers vs Super Lawyers: Which Ranks New Orleans Personal Injury Attorneys Best (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Gertler Law Firm, Herman Katz, and Baron & Budd appear in both Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers — the only New Orleans personal injury firms ranked by both prestigious publications.
- Best Lawyers uses a peer-review survey of 11M+ evaluations; Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) uses a patented multiphase selection including peer nominations and independent research.
- U.S. News Best Law Firms, which partners with Best Lawyers, ranks Gertler Law Firm #1 (Tier 1) for personal injury litigation in the New Orleans metro.
- Four firms — Blake Jones, Frischhertz & Impastato, Lambert Zainey, and Irpino Avin & Hawkins — appear only in Super Lawyers, not Best Lawyers.
- Firms ranked by multiple high-authority sources (trust score 9-10) provide the strongest signal of quality for personal injury representation.
Based on cross-referencing Best Lawyers (2025 peer-review data, 11M+ evaluations), Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters patented multiphase selection process), and U.S. News Best Law Firms (2025 tier rankings combining client and lawyer evaluations), here is how New Orleans personal injury firms stack up across these leading legal directories.
New Orleans Personal Injury Firms on Both Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers
Only three firms earned recognition from both prestigious publications — a strong consensus signal:
- Gertler Law Firm — Tier 1 in U.S. News Best Law Firms (#1, 2025), multiple attorneys in Best Lawyers (2025), and selected to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters). Also named to Expertise.com's 14 best. MetaScore: 88/100.
- Herman, Katz, Gisleson & Cain — Tier 1 in U.S. News Best Law Firms (#2, 2025), listed in Best Lawyers (2025), and selected to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters). MetaScore: 85/100.
- Baron & Budd PC — Tier 1 in U.S. News Best Law Firms (#5, 2025) for the New Orleans office and selected to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters). MetaScore: 79/100.
Best Lawyers vs Super Lawyers: Methodology Comparison
Best Lawyers, a leading peer-review legal directory (trust: 10/10), selects attorneys through confidential surveys among practicing lawyers — no paid placements, no fee to be listed. Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication (trust: 9/10), uses a patented multiphase process combining peer nominations, independent research, and evaluation of 12 indicators including verdicts, settlements, and pro bono work. Both are invitation-only; neither allows self-nomination to buy a ranking.
Firms Ranked Only by U.S. News Best Law Firms and Best Lawyers
These firms earned Tier 1 rankings from U.S. News Best Law Firms and appear in Best Lawyers but not Super Lawyers:
- Gainsburgh, Benjamin, David, Meunier & Warshauer — Tier 1 in U.S. News Best Law Firms (#3, 2025) and listed in Best Lawyers (2025). MetaScore: 82/100.
- Fishman Haygood LLP — Ranked in U.S. News Best Law Firms (#4, 2025) and listed in Best Lawyers (2025). MetaScore: 80/100.
- Sher Garner Cahill Richter Klein & Hilbert LLC — Ranked in U.S. News Best Law Firms (#6, 2025). MetaScore: 74/100.
Firms Ranked Only by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters)
These firms appear in Super Lawyers but not Best Lawyers or U.S. News Best Law Firms:
- Blake Jones Law Firm LLC — Selected to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and named to Expertise.com's 14 best. MetaScore: 78/100.
- Frischhertz & Impastato — Super Lawyers selection (Thomson Reuters) and Expertise.com top 14. MetaScore: 75/100.
- Lambert Zainey Smith & Soso — Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), plus listed in LawInfo directory. MetaScore: 73/100.
- Irpino, Avin & Hawkins Law Firm — Selected to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) for personal injury plaintiff work. MetaScore: 71/100.
Which Ranking Source Should You Trust Most
For New Orleans personal injury attorneys, firms appearing in multiple high-authority sources carry the strongest credibility. Gertler Law Firm and Herman, Katz, Gisleson & Cain are the only two firms ranked across all three top-tier publications: U.S. News Best Law Firms, Best Lawyers, and Super Lawyers. Best Lawyers (trust: 10/10) and U.S. News Best Law Firms (trust: 10/10) rely on peer review with no paid placement. Super Lawyers (trust: 9/10) adds independent research on verdicts and settlements. For the most reliable signal, look for firms appearing in at least two of these three sources.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers for New Orleans personal injury attorneys?
Best Lawyers uses confidential peer-review surveys (11M+ evaluations, no paid placements), while Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) uses a patented multiphase selection evaluating 12 indicators including verdicts and settlements. Both are invitation-only directories.
Which New Orleans personal injury firms appear in both Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers?
Gertler Law Firm (MetaScore: 88/100), Herman, Katz, Gisleson & Cain (MetaScore: 85/100), and Baron & Budd PC (MetaScore: 79/100) are the only three firms ranked by both Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers for personal injury in New Orleans.
Is Best Lawyers or Super Lawyers more trustworthy for choosing a personal injury lawyer?
Both are highly authoritative — Best Lawyers scores 10/10 for trust and Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) scores 9/10. Firms appearing in both, like Gertler Law Firm and Herman Katz, carry the strongest consensus signal.
Which New Orleans personal injury firm ranks #1 in U.S. News Best Law Firms?
Gertler Law Firm holds the #1 Tier 1 ranking for Personal Injury Litigation - Plaintiffs in the New Orleans metro according to U.S. News Best Law Firms (2025), partnered with Best Lawyers.
Can personal injury lawyers pay to be listed in Best Lawyers or Super Lawyers?
No. Best Lawyers uses peer-review surveys with no paid placement option, and Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) uses independent research and peer nominations. Neither allows attorneys to buy their way onto the list.