Best Consumer-Rated vs. Peer-Rated Personal Injury Lawyers in St. Louis (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Only 2 of 8 U.S. News Tier 1 firms (The Simon Law Firm and OnderLaw) also rank in the Yelp Top 10 and hold perfect Avvo 10.0 ratings — making them the strongest dual-rated firms in St. Louis.
- DM Injury Law ranks #1 on Yelp and appears in Best Lawyers but holds no U.S. News Tier 1 ranking, illustrating how consumer and peer systems can diverge.
- Brown & Crouppen, P.C. appears in 6 sources including Yelp Top 10 (#3), National Trial Lawyers Top 100, and St. Louis Post-Dispatch Best Law Firm — but is absent from U.S. News Tier 1.
- Peer-review directories like U.S. News Best Law Firms (trust 10/10) and Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication (trust 9/10), weight attorney credentials and case outcomes, while Yelp (trust 6/10) and Avvo (trust 7/10) weight client satisfaction.
- The Bruning Law Firm has 1,200+ five-star client reviews and ThreeBestRated recognition but no U.S. News Tier 1 ranking, showing strong consumer approval without top peer placement.
Based on cross-referencing 14 sources including U.S. News & Best Lawyers 2025 Best Law Firms (trust 10/10), Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication (trust 9/10), Avvo (trust 7/10), and Yelp (trust 6/10), here is how consumer-rated and peer-rated personal injury lawyers in St. Louis compare.
Top U.S. News Tier 1 Personal Injury Firms in St. Louis
Peer-review rankings from U.S. News & Best Lawyers 2025 evaluate firms through attorney credentials, peer assessments, and case outcomes. All 6 firms below hold the highest Tier 1 designation:
- The Simon Law Firm, P.C. — #1 Tier 1 ranking (U.S. News Best Law Firms, 2025); John G. Simon named 2026 Lawyer of the Year (Best Lawyers)
- OnderLaw, LLC — #2 Tier 1 ranking (U.S. News Best Law Firms, 2025); 6 attorneys named to Best Lawyers 2025
- O'Leary, Shelton, Corrigan, Peterson, Dalton & Quillin LLC — #3 Tier 1 ranking (U.S. News Best Law Firms, 2025); multiple Super Lawyers honorees
- Gray Ritter Graham — #4 Tier 1 ranking (U.S. News Best Law Firms, 2025); attorneys named Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters)
- Lieser Law Firm, LLC — #5 Tier 1 ranking (U.S. News Best Law Firms, 2025); Shaun Lieser recognized by Best Lawyers since 2025
- Growe Eisen Karlen Eilerts — #6 Tier 1 ranking (U.S. News Best Law Firms, 2025); attorneys named Super Lawyers
Top Yelp-Ranked Personal Injury Lawyers in St. Louis
Consumer rankings from Yelp's 2025 Top 10 reflect client reviews and satisfaction scores:
- DM Injury Law — #1 on Yelp Top 10 (2025); also recognized by Best Lawyers, $1B+ recovered since 2013
- Goldblatt + Singer, P.C. — #2 on Yelp Top 10 (2025); AV Preeminent rated by Martindale-Hubbell, $550M+ recovered since 1949
- Brown & Crouppen, P.C. — #3 on Yelp Top 10 (2025); multiple attorneys named National Trial Lawyers Top 100; St. Louis Post-Dispatch Best Law Firm 2024
- OnderLaw, LLC — #4 on Yelp Top 10 (2025); James G. Onder holds perfect 10.0 Avvo rating
- Holland Injury Law, LLC — #5 on Yelp Top 10 (2025); William K. Holland recognized by Best Lawyers, $250M+ recovered over 33 years
- The Bruning Law Firm — #6 on Yelp Top 10 (2025); 1,200+ five-star reviews; ThreeBestRated top 3 selection
Firms That Rank High on Both Consumer and Peer Reviews
Only 2 firms appear in both U.S. News Tier 1 and the Yelp Top 10 while also holding perfect Avvo scores:
- The Simon Law Firm, P.C. — U.S. News Tier 1 #1, Avvo 10.0, Super Lawyers #1 in Missouri for 7 consecutive years, Expertise.com top 11 selection
- OnderLaw, LLC — U.S. News Tier 1 #2, Yelp Top 10 #4, Avvo 10.0, St. Louis Post-Dispatch Best Law Firm 3 consecutive years (2023–2025)
Schlapprizzi PC also bridges both systems: Toni Schlapprizzi was named 2025 Lawyer of the Year by Best Lawyers and holds an Avvo Excellent rating, while Don Schlapprizzi received MATA's Outstanding Service Award (Missouri Lawyers).
Firms That Rank High on Consumer Reviews Only
These firms score well on consumer platforms but do not hold U.S. News Tier 1 rankings:
- DM Injury Law — #1 on Yelp (2025) and listed by Best Lawyers, but absent from U.S. News Tier 1; $1B+ recovered since 2013
- Brown & Crouppen, P.C. — #3 on Yelp, National Trial Lawyers Top 100, Million Dollar Advocates Forum member, St. Louis Post-Dispatch Best Law Firm — but no U.S. News Tier 1 placement
- The Bruning Law Firm — Yelp #6, ThreeBestRated top 3, 1,200+ five-star reviews, Million Dollar Advocates Forum — no U.S. News Tier 1 ranking
- Cantor Injury Law — Avvo 10.0 Superb, AV Preeminent Martindale-Hubbell, Expertise.com top selection, $500M+ recovered in Missouri — no U.S. News Tier 1 ranking
Frequently Asked Questions
Which St. Louis personal injury lawyers rank high on both Yelp and U.S. News?
The Simon Law Firm, P.C. (U.S. News Tier 1 #1, Avvo 10.0) and OnderLaw, LLC (U.S. News Tier 1 #2, Yelp Top 10 #4, Avvo 10.0) are the only firms that appear in both the U.S. News Tier 1 list and top consumer review platforms.
Why is DM Injury Law #1 on Yelp but not in U.S. News Tier 1?
DM Injury Law ranks #1 on Yelp's 2025 Top 10 and is recognized by Best Lawyers, but U.S. News Best Law Firms Tier 1 rankings weight peer evaluations and sustained attorney credentials differently than client review volume, resulting in different placements.
Are peer-reviewed rankings more reliable than consumer reviews for choosing a personal injury lawyer?
Peer-reviewed sources like U.S. News Best Law Firms (trust 10/10) and Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication (trust 9/10), evaluate attorney credentials and case outcomes, while Yelp (trust 6/10) and Avvo (trust 7/10) reflect client satisfaction. Firms appearing in both systems — like The Simon Law Firm and OnderLaw — offer the strongest combined signal.
Which St. Louis personal injury firms have the most cross-source recognition?
OnderLaw, LLC appears in 7 sources including U.S. News Tier 1, Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, Yelp, and St. Louis Post-Dispatch. The Simon Law Firm, P.C. appears in 6 sources including U.S. News Tier 1 #1, Chambers USA, and Super Lawyers #1 in Missouri for 7 consecutive years.
Does Brown & Crouppen have peer-review recognition despite missing U.S. News Tier 1?
Yes. Brown & Crouppen, P.C. appears in 6 sources including National Trial Lawyers Top 100, Million Dollar Advocates Forum, St. Louis Post-Dispatch Best Law Firm, and Yelp Top 10 #3 — but Brown & Crouppen does not hold a U.S. News Tier 1 ranking for personal injury litigation.