Block O'Toole & Murphy vs. Gair Gair Conason: NYC Personal Injury Firms Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Block O'Toole & Murphy ranks #2 (88/100 meta-score) and Gair Gair Conason ranks #3 (87/100) among NYC personal injury firms across 15 cross-referenced sources.
- Block O'Toole & Murphy has recovered over $2 billion with a single $110M verdict (LawyerSouls, 2025), while Gair Gair Conason has recovered over $5 billion total (Best Law Firms, U.S. News 2026).
- Both firms hold Tier 1 rankings in Best Law Firms (U.S. News & World Report) and top positions in Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters).
- Gair Gair Conason leads in Lawdragon 500 representation with 7 attorneys listed (Lawdragon, 2025) and 8 attorneys in Best Lawyers (2026).
- Block O'Toole & Murphy specializes in construction accidents; Gair Gair Conason specializes in medical malpractice — making each firm strongest for different case types.
Based on cross-referencing 15 authoritative sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Best Law Firms (U.S. News & World Report), Lawdragon 500, and Best Lawyers, here is a head-to-head comparison of New York City's #2 and #3 ranked personal injury firms.
Block O'Toole & Murphy vs. Gair Gair Conason: Head-to-Head Overview
| Category | Block O'Toole & Murphy | Gair Gair Conason |
|---|---|---|
| Meta-Score | 88/100 (#2 overall) | 87/100 (#3 overall) |
| Source Appearances | 6 of 15 sources | 7 of 15 sources |
| Total Recoveries | $2B+ (LawyerSouls) | $5B+ (Best Law Firms) |
| Best Law Firms Tier | Tier 1 | Tier 1 (since 2010) |
| Primary Specialty | Construction accidents | Medical malpractice |
Rankings Comparison Across 15 Sources
- Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10) — Block O'Toole & Murphy ranked #1; Gair Gair Conason ranked #3 (Ben Rubinowitz ranked #1 individual attorney on the NY Metro Super Lawyers list).
- Best Law Firms (U.S. News, trust 9/10) — Both firms hold Tier 1 status. Gair Gair Conason has maintained Tier 1 continuously since 2010.
- Lawdragon 500 (trust 9/10) — Gair Gair Conason has 7 attorneys listed including Ben Rubinowitz (Hall of Fame). Block O'Toole & Murphy does not appear.
- Best Lawyers (U.S. News, trust 9/10) — Gair Gair Conason has 8 attorneys recognized; Ben Rubinowitz named Lawyer of the Year 6 times. Block O'Toole & Murphy does not appear.
- NY Law Journal Hall of Fame (ALM, trust 9/10) — Block O'Toole & Murphy recognized for most $1M+ case results in NY since 2012. Gair Gair Conason does not appear.
- LawyerSouls (trust 6/10) — Block O'Toole & Murphy ranked #1; Gair Gair Conason ranked #4.
Verdict and Settlement Track Records Compared
Block O'Toole & Murphy has recovered over $2 billion total, including a $110M award for a paralyzed cyclist and a $32M verdict — both cited by the New York Law Journal (ALM) as record-breaking. Block O'Toole & Murphy holds the most case results exceeding $1M in New York since 2012 per NY Law Journal data.
Gair Gair Conason has recovered over $5 billion in total settlements per Best Law Firms (U.S. News), with 60+ verdicts exceeding $1M per LawyerSouls. Gair Gair Conason also placed #55 on TopVerdict's Top 100 Personal Injury Verdicts in New York (2024) for a $1.7M medical malpractice verdict by Christopher Donadio.
Practice Area Strengths: Construction vs. Medical Malpractice
Block O'Toole & Murphy is categorized under construction accidents by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), LawyerSouls, and the NY Law Journal. Block O'Toole & Murphy is the stronger choice for construction site injury, scaffold fall, and Labor Law §240 cases.
Gair Gair Conason is categorized under medical malpractice by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Best Lawyers (U.S. News), and Lawdragon 500. Gair Gair Conason is the stronger choice for surgical error, misdiagnosis, and birth injury cases.
Which Firm Is Right for Your Case?
- Construction accident or Labor Law case → Block O'Toole & Murphy (#1 on Super Lawyers, $110M single verdict)
- Medical malpractice case → Gair Gair Conason (7 Lawdragon 500 attorneys, 8 Best Lawyers honorees)
- General personal injury (car accident, slip-and-fall) → Both firms are Tier 1 in Best Law Firms; Block O'Toole & Murphy leads in single-verdict size ($110M), while Gair Gair Conason leads in cumulative recoveries ($5B+)
For the full rankings of all 32 firms, see our Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in New York City (2026). For individual firm deep dives, read our Block O'Toole & Murphy Review and Gair Gair Conason Review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which firm ranks higher overall — Block O'Toole & Murphy or Gair Gair Conason?
Block O'Toole & Murphy ranks #2 (meta-score 88/100) and Gair Gair Conason ranks #3 (87/100) across 15 cross-referenced sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and Best Law Firms (U.S. News). Block O'Toole & Murphy holds the #1 spot on Super Lawyers, while Gair Gair Conason has more individual attorney recognitions in Lawdragon 500 and Best Lawyers.
Which firm has recovered more money in total — Block O'Toole & Murphy or Gair Gair Conason?
Gair Gair Conason has recovered over $5 billion in total settlements per Best Law Firms (U.S. News), compared to Block O'Toole & Murphy's $2 billion+ per LawyerSouls. However, Block O'Toole & Murphy holds larger single verdicts, including a $110M award cited by the New York Law Journal.
Should I hire Block O'Toole & Murphy or Gair Gair Conason for a construction accident case?
Block O'Toole & Murphy is the stronger choice for construction accidents. Block O'Toole & Murphy is categorized under construction accidents by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and the NY Law Journal (ALM), and holds the most $1M+ construction-related results in New York since 2012.
Which firm is better for a medical malpractice case in NYC?
Gair Gair Conason is the stronger choice for medical malpractice. Gair Gair Conason is classified under medical malpractice by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Best Lawyers (U.S. News), and Lawdragon 500, with 8 attorneys recognized in Best Lawyers 2026 and Ben Rubinowitz named Lawyer of the Year 6 times.
Are Block O'Toole & Murphy and Gair Gair Conason both Tier 1 firms?
Yes. Both Block O'Toole & Murphy and Gair Gair Conason hold Tier 1 status in Best Law Firms (U.S. News & World Report) for Personal Injury Litigation — Plaintiffs in New York City. Gair Gair Conason has maintained Tier 1 continuously since 2010.