Best Personal Injury Law Firms in Cincinnati with 30+ Years Experience (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Freking Myers & Reul LLC leads with 75+ years combined experience, an AV Martindale-Hubbell rating, and rankings in Super Lawyers, U.S. News, and Expertise.com (2026).
- Crowley Ahlers & Roth LPA has served Cincinnati personal injury clients for over 65 years, per Expertise.com's 2026 selection.
- The Moore Law Firm and Brown, Lippert & Laite each bring 50+ years of experience, with The Moore Law Firm earning a 10.0 Avvo rating and U.S. News 2026 recognition.
- The Butler Trial Firm's Rob Butler has over 30 years of personal injury practice, featured in both LawInfo and Lawyers.com directories.
- Five of the six firms listed appear in multiple authoritative sources, signaling cross-verified credibility.
Based on cross-referencing 10 authoritative sources including Super Lawyers (a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication), U.S. News Best Law Firms 2026 rankings, Best Lawyers in America, and Expertise.com, here are Cincinnati's top personal injury law firms with 30 or more years of experience, ranked by longevity and source recognition.
Top Cincinnati Personal Injury Firms by Years of Experience
- Freking Myers & Reul LLC — 75+ years combined experience; Martindale-Hubbell AV Rating; Million Dollar Advocates Forum member (Super Lawyers 2026, U.S. News 2026, Expertise.com 2026, Yelp 2026)
- Crowley Ahlers & Roth LPA — 65+ years protecting personal injury clients; selected by Expertise.com 2026 and listed in Lawyers.com directory
- The Moore Law Firm — 50+ years experience; 10.0 Avvo rating; ranked by Super Lawyers 2026 (#2), U.S. News 2026 (#3), Expertise.com 2026, and TrustAnalytica (#2)
- Brown, Lippert & Laite — 50+ years representing injured individuals; 100+ trials and arbitrations completed (Expertise.com 2026, Lawyers.com)
- The Butler Trial Firm — Rob Butler brings 30+ years of personal injury practice (LawInfo, Lawyers.com)
- O'Connor, Acciani & Levy — Barry Levy named Super Lawyers honoree 11 consecutive years; Henry Acciani and Barry Levy both named to National Trial Lawyers Top 100; $4.9M settlement highlighted by ThreeBestRated; ranked in 7 of 10 sources surveyed
Firms with 50+ Years of Experience
Freking Myers & Reul LLC holds the longest combined track record at 75+ years and is one of only four Cincinnati personal injury firms ranked by both prestigious Super Lawyers 2026 and U.S. News Best Law Firms 2026. Freking Myers & Reul LLC also earned Martindale-Hubbell's AV Preeminent rating and Million Dollar Advocates Forum membership, per Expertise.com.
The Moore Law Firm has 50+ years of experience and the highest Avvo rating (10.0) among Cincinnati personal injury firms. The Moore Law Firm appeared in 4 of 10 sources, including a #2 ranking from Super Lawyers 2026 and #3 from U.S. News 2026. For a detailed profile, see our Moore Law Firm review.
Brown, Lippert & Laite has represented injured individuals for over 50 years with 100+ trials and arbitrations, earning selection by Expertise.com 2026.
Firms with 30+ Years of Experience
Crowley Ahlers & Roth LPA has served Cincinnati families in personal injury cases for over 65 years, per Expertise.com 2026 and Lawyers.com. Crowley Ahlers & Roth LPA is among the longest-operating personal injury practices in the Cincinnati metro.
The Butler Trial Firm features attorney Rob Butler with 30+ years of personal injury practice, recognized by both LawInfo and Lawyers.com. The Butler Trial Firm specializes in representing individual injury clients across the Greater Cincinnati area.
O'Connor, Acciani & Levy appeared in 7 of 10 sources — the most of any Cincinnati personal injury firm surveyed — including Super Lawyers 2026 (#1), U.S. News 2026 (#2), and National Trial Lawyers Top 100. O'Connor, Acciani & Levy's $4.9M settlement was highlighted by ThreeBestRated. See our full O'Connor, Acciani & Levy review.
For the complete ranked list of all 16 firms, see our Top 16 Personal Injury Lawyers in Cincinnati (2026).
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Cincinnati personal injury firm has the most years of experience?
Freking Myers & Reul LLC has the longest combined track record at 75+ years, with Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating and rankings in Super Lawyers 2026, U.S. News 2026, and Expertise.com 2026.
Which experienced Cincinnati personal injury firms are ranked by both Super Lawyers and U.S. News?
Freking Myers & Reul LLC and The Moore Law Firm (50+ years, 10.0 Avvo rating) are both ranked by Super Lawyers 2026 (Thomson Reuters) and U.S. News Best Law Firms 2026. O'Connor, Acciani & Levy also appears in both plus 5 additional sources.
Are there Cincinnati personal injury firms with 50+ years of trial experience?
Brown, Lippert & Laite has 50+ years of practice and has completed 100+ trials and arbitrations, per Expertise.com 2026. The Moore Law Firm also has 50+ years experience with a 10.0 Avvo rating.
How many sources were used to rank experienced Cincinnati personal injury firms?
Rankings were cross-referenced across 10 sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), U.S. News Best Law Firms, Best Lawyers in America, Expertise.com, and National Trial Lawyers Top 100. O'Connor, Acciani & Levy appeared in 7 of 10 sources — the most of any firm.
Does experience matter when choosing a Cincinnati personal injury lawyer?
Firms with 30+ years have typically handled thousands of cases and hundreds of trials. For example, Brown, Lippert & Laite has completed 100+ trials, and O'Connor, Acciani & Levy secured a $4.9M settlement highlighted by ThreeBestRated.