Malek & Malek Review: Personal Injury Lawyers in Columbus (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Malek & Malek Law Firm appeared in 4 of 5 sources surveyed, including Super Lawyers (a Thomson Reuters publication) and Expertise.com — tied for the most appearances among all Columbus personal injury firms.
- Malek & Malek earned a 71/100 MetaScore, ranking #3 overall behind only The Fitch Law Firm (82/100) and The Donahey Law Firm (78/100).
- Malek & Malek was ranked #5 by Super Lawyers, #4 by Expertise.com, #3 by Entrepreneurs of Columbus, and #4 by ELOA — showing consistent mid-top placement across all sources.
- Only 3 Columbus personal injury firms achieved 4-source cross-referencing: The Fitch Law Firm, The Donahey Law Firm, and Malek & Malek Law Firm.
Based on cross-referencing 5 authoritative sources including Super Lawyers (a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication), Expertise.com, LawInfo, and ELOA, Malek & Malek Law Firm ranks #3 among Columbus personal injury firms with a 71/100 MetaScore and appearances in 4 of 5 directories surveyed.
Malek & Malek — Rankings Summary
Malek & Malek Law Firm earned a 71/100 MetaScore based on a weighted formula: appearances across sources (40%), average rank position (30%), source authority (20%), and credentials (10%). Malek & Malek appeared in 4 sources — tied with The Fitch Law Firm (82/100, 4 appearances) and The Donahey Law Firm (78/100, 4 appearances) for the most cross-referenced personal injury firms in Columbus. No other Columbus firm appeared in more than 3 sources.
Source-by-Source Breakdown for Malek & Malek
- Malek & Malek — #5 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, Trust 9/10). Super Lawyers is a prestigious attorney rating service that uses peer nominations, independent research, and peer evaluations.
- Malek & Malek — #4 on Expertise.com (Trust 6/10). Expertise.com is a review aggregator that scores firms on reputation, credibility, experience, availability, and professionalism.
- Malek & Malek — #3 on Entrepreneurs of Columbus (Trust 4/10). Entrepreneurs of Columbus is a local business directory covering top-rated service providers.
- Malek & Malek — #4 on ELOA (Trust 4/10). ELOA ranks personal injury lawyers based on professional achievements and client outcomes.
Malek & Malek's strongest ranking came from Entrepreneurs of Columbus (#3), while Malek & Malek's most authoritative placement was #5 on Super Lawyers, the highest-trust source in the dataset.
How Malek & Malek Compares to Other Columbus Firms
| Rank | Firm | MetaScore | Appearances |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Fitch Law Firm | 82/100 | 4 sources |
| 2 | The Donahey Law Firm | 78/100 | 4 sources |
| 3 | Malek & Malek Law Firm | 71/100 | 4 sources |
| 4 | Leeseberg Tuttle | 68/100 | 3 sources |
| 5 | Schiff & Associates | 65/100 | 3 sources |
Malek & Malek Law Firm outranked Leeseberg Tuttle (68/100, ranked by Super Lawyers #3, Expertise.com #5, and LawInfo #2) and Schiff & Associates (65/100, ranked by Super Lawyers #4, Expertise.com #6, and Entrepreneurs of Columbus #4). The gap between Malek & Malek and the #2-ranked Donahey Law Firm is 7 points, driven primarily by The Donahey Law Firm's higher average rank positions across shared sources.
For a full ranking of all 20 firms, see Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Columbus, Ohio (2026). For head-to-head analysis, see Leeseberg Tuttle vs. Schiff & Associates vs. Malek & Malek: Columbus Personal Injury Firms Compared (2026).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Malek & Malek Law Firm listed on Super Lawyers?
Yes. Malek & Malek Law Firm is ranked #5 on Super Lawyers' Columbus personal injury plaintiff list. Super Lawyers is a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication that uses peer nominations and independent research.
How does Malek & Malek rank compared to other Columbus personal injury firms?
Malek & Malek Law Firm ranks #3 overall with a 71/100 MetaScore, behind The Fitch Law Firm (82/100) and The Donahey Law Firm (78/100). Malek & Malek appeared in 4 of 5 sources — tied for the most of any Columbus firm.
What sources rank Malek & Malek Law Firm in Columbus?
Malek & Malek appears in 4 directories: Super Lawyers (#5), Expertise.com (#4), Entrepreneurs of Columbus (#3), and ELOA (#4). Only The Fitch Law Firm and The Donahey Law Firm matched Malek & Malek's 4-source breadth.
Is Malek & Malek better ranked than Leeseberg Tuttle or Schiff & Associates?
Yes. Malek & Malek Law Firm (71/100, 4 sources) outranks both Leeseberg Tuttle (68/100, 3 sources) and Schiff & Associates (65/100, 3 sources) based on MetaScore calculations across all surveyed directories.