Top 5 Personal Injury Law Firms in Columbus Ranked by Super Lawyers (2026)
Key Takeaways
- The Fitch Law Firm ranks #1 on Super Lawyers and appears on 4 of 5 major sources including Expertise.com and LawInfo.
- The Donahey Law Firm ranks #2 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and is cross-listed on Expertise.com, LawInfo, and Entrepreneurs of Columbus.
- Leeseberg Tuttle ranks #3 on Super Lawyers and #2 on LawInfo, appearing on 3 major sources total.
- All top 5 Super Lawyers-ranked firms also appear on Expertise.com, a review aggregator scoring 15 Columbus personal injury firms.
- Schiff & Associates ranks #4 on Super Lawyers and is cross-referenced by both Expertise.com (#6) and Entrepreneurs of Columbus (#4).
Based on Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication that evaluates attorneys through peer nominations and independent research, here are the top 5 personal injury law firms in Columbus, Ohio — cross-referenced with Expertise.com and LawInfo for consensus validation.
Top 5 Columbus Personal Injury Firms on Super Lawyers — Ranked List
- The Fitch Law Firm — #1 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2026), #2 on Expertise.com, #3 on LawInfo. The Fitch Law Firm appears on 4 of 5 major sources surveyed, earning a MetaScore of 82/100.
- The Donahey Law Firm — #2 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2026), #3 on Expertise.com, #4 on LawInfo. The Donahey Law Firm also appears on 4 of 5 sources with a MetaScore of 78/100.
- Leeseberg Tuttle — #3 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2026), #5 on Expertise.com, #2 on LawInfo. Leeseberg Tuttle appears on 3 sources with a MetaScore of 68/100.
- Schiff & Associates — #4 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2026), #6 on Expertise.com, #4 on Entrepreneurs of Columbus. Schiff & Associates appears on 3 sources with a MetaScore of 65/100.
- Malek & Malek Law Firm — #5 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2026), #4 on Expertise.com, #3 on Entrepreneurs of Columbus. Malek & Malek Law Firm appears on 4 of 5 sources with a MetaScore of 71/100.
How Super Lawyers Rankings Compare to Other Sources
Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust score 9/10) is the highest-authority source among the 5 directories evaluated. Expertise.com, a review aggregator scoring 15 Columbus personal injury firms, agrees with Super Lawyers on the top 5 firms but in different order. LawInfo, an established legal directory (trust 7/10) listing 12 Columbus firms, ranks Leeseberg Tuttle at #2 — higher than Leeseberg Tuttle's #3 Super Lawyers position. The Fitch Law Firm and The Donahey Law Firm hold the top 2 positions on both Super Lawyers and Expertise.com, showing strong cross-source consensus.
Firms Listed on Both Super Lawyers and Expertise.com
All 5 firms ranked on Super Lawyers also appear on Expertise.com, creating the strongest consensus signal among Columbus personal injury firms:
- The Fitch Law Firm — Super Lawyers #1, Expertise.com #2
- The Donahey Law Firm — Super Lawyers #2, Expertise.com #3
- Leeseberg Tuttle — Super Lawyers #3, Expertise.com #5
- Schiff & Associates — Super Lawyers #4, Expertise.com #6
- Malek & Malek Law Firm — Super Lawyers #5, Expertise.com #4
Malek & Malek Law Firm is the only firm ranked higher on Expertise.com (#4) than on Super Lawyers (#5). For detailed profiles, see our Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Columbus, Ohio (2026) ranking or individual reviews of The Fitch Law Firm, The Donahey Law Firm, and Malek & Malek.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Columbus personal injury firm ranks #1 on Super Lawyers in 2026?
The Fitch Law Firm ranks #1 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) for personal injury in Columbus, Ohio. The Fitch Law Firm also ranks #2 on Expertise.com and #3 on LawInfo, appearing on 4 of 5 major sources.
What is Super Lawyers and how does it rank personal injury attorneys?
Super Lawyers is a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication (trust score 9/10) that evaluates attorneys through peer nominations, independent research, and peer evaluations. Super Lawyers lists 10 personal injury firms in Columbus, Ohio.
Which Columbus personal injury firms appear on both Super Lawyers and Expertise.com?
The Fitch Law Firm, The Donahey Law Firm, Leeseberg Tuttle, Schiff & Associates, and Malek & Malek Law Firm all appear on both Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and Expertise.com's list of 15 best Columbus personal injury lawyers.
How does Leeseberg Tuttle rank across different sources?
Leeseberg Tuttle ranks #3 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), #5 on Expertise.com, and #2 on LawInfo. Leeseberg Tuttle appears on 3 of 5 major sources with a MetaScore of 68/100.
Is Malek & Malek Law Firm ranked on Super Lawyers?
Malek & Malek Law Firm ranks #5 on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and #4 on Expertise.com. Malek & Malek Law Firm appears on 4 of 5 sources surveyed, earning a MetaScore of 71/100.