Best Personal Injury Law Firms in Oklahoma (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Cain Law earned the highest MetaScore (82/100) across 3 sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and Elite Litigators
- Cunningham & Mears ranked #1 on both Super Lawyers Oklahoma City and ThreeBestRated, appearing in 3 sources total
- Richardson Richardson Boudreaux leads Tulsa rankings as #1 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025 and #2 on Elite Litigators
- 7 firms appeared in 3+ sources, signaling strong cross-source consensus for Oklahoma personal injury representation
- Rankings cross-reference 7 sources covering 23 firms statewide, weighted by appearance frequency (40%), ranking position (30%), and source authority (20%)
Based on cross-referencing 7 authoritative sources — including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), Expertise.com, and Elite Litigators — here are the best personal injury law firms in Oklahoma for 2026, ranked by MetaScore.
Top Personal Injury Firms in Oklahoma — Statewide Rankings
- Cain Law — MetaScore 82/100, 3 sources: #1 on Elite Litigators 2025, #2 on Expertise.com, #3 on Super Lawyers OKC 2025
- Cunningham & Mears — MetaScore 78/100, 3 sources: #1 on Super Lawyers OKC 2025, #1 on ThreeBestRated, #2 on OnTopList
- Abel Law Firm — MetaScore 72/100, 2 sources: #4 on Super Lawyers OKC 2025, #3 on Elite Litigators 2025
- Stipe & Belote LLP — MetaScore 71/100, 3 sources: #5 on Super Lawyers OKC, #4 on OnTopList, #3 on Rviewo 2026
- Richardson Richardson Boudreaux — MetaScore 68/100, 2 sources: #1 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025, #2 on Elite Litigators 2025
Top Personal Injury Lawyers in Oklahoma City
- Cain Law — #1 Elite Litigators, #2 Expertise.com, #3 Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters). Appeared in 3 of 5 OKC-focused sources.
- Cunningham & Mears — #1 Super Lawyers OKC, #1 ThreeBestRated, #2 OnTopList. Cunningham & Mears is the only OKC firm ranked #1 by the prestigious Super Lawyers directory.
- Bryan Garrett PLLC — MetaScore 70/100, 3 sources: #3 Expertise.com, #5 OnTopList, #4 Rviewo 2026.
- Nix & Diesselhorst — MetaScore 69/100, 3 sources: #4 Expertise.com, #6 OnTopList, #4 Elite Litigators 2025.
- Dan Davis Law — MetaScore 65/100, 3 sources: #5 Expertise.com, #2 ThreeBestRated, #5 Rviewo 2026.
- McIntyre Law PC — MetaScore 62/100, ranked #1 on both OnTopList and Rviewo 2026.
- Parrish DeVaughn Injury Lawyers — #2 on Rviewo 2026.
- AP Injury Lawyers — 2 sources: #8 Rviewo, #3 ThreeBestRated.
Top Personal Injury Lawyers in Tulsa
- Richardson Richardson Boudreaux — #1 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025 (Thomson Reuters), #2 on Elite Litigators 2025. Richardson Richardson Boudreaux is the top-ranked Tulsa personal injury firm across both prestigious sources.
- Martin Jean & Jackson — #2 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025.
- Graves McLain Injury Lawyers — MetaScore 60/100, 2 sources: #3 Super Lawyers Tulsa, #5 Elite Litigators.
- Frasier, Frasier & Hickman LLP — #4 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025.
- Carr & Carr Injury Attorneys — #5 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025.
Oklahoma Firms With Multi-Source Consensus
Seven Oklahoma personal injury firms appeared in 3+ independent sources, a strong consensus signal:
- Cain Law — Super Lawyers + Expertise.com + Elite Litigators (3 sources)
- Cunningham & Mears — Super Lawyers + OnTopList + ThreeBestRated (3 sources)
- Stipe & Belote LLP — Super Lawyers + OnTopList + Rviewo (3 sources)
- Bryan Garrett PLLC — Expertise.com + OnTopList + Rviewo (3 sources)
- Nix & Diesselhorst — Expertise.com + OnTopList + Elite Litigators (3 sources)
- Dan Davis Law — Expertise.com + ThreeBestRated + Rviewo (3 sources)
- Ryan Bisher Ryan & Simons — OnTopList + Rviewo (2 sources)
Cain Law and Cunningham & Mears both appeared in the prestigious Super Lawyers directory (Thomson Reuters) alongside mid-tier review aggregators, giving Cain Law and Cunningham & Mears the strongest cross-tier validation statewide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which personal injury law firm is ranked #1 in Oklahoma for 2026?
Cain Law earned the highest MetaScore (82/100) statewide, ranked #1 by Elite Litigators 2025 and appearing in 3 sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters). In Tulsa, Richardson Richardson Boudreaux holds the #1 spot on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025.
What are the top-rated personal injury firms in Oklahoma City?
Cunningham & Mears ranked #1 on Super Lawyers OKC 2025 (Thomson Reuters) and #1 on ThreeBestRated. Cain Law ranked #1 on Elite Litigators and #2 on Expertise.com. Both firms appeared in 3 independent sources.
Which Tulsa personal injury lawyers are highest rated?
Richardson Richardson Boudreaux ranked #1 on Super Lawyers Tulsa 2025 and #2 on Elite Litigators 2025. Martin Jean & Jackson ranked #2 on Super Lawyers Tulsa, and Graves McLain Injury Lawyers appeared in both Super Lawyers Tulsa (#3) and Elite Litigators (#5).
How were these Oklahoma personal injury lawyer rankings determined?
Rankings cross-reference 7 sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), Expertise.com, Elite Litigators, OnTopList, ThreeBestRated, and Rviewo, weighted by appearance frequency (40%), ranking position (30%), source authority (20%), and credentials (10%).
Which Oklahoma personal injury firms appear in the most ranking sources?
Six firms appeared in 3 sources each: Cain Law, Cunningham & Mears, Stipe & Belote LLP, Bryan Garrett PLLC, Nix & Diesselhorst, and Dan Davis Law. Cain Law and Cunningham & Mears scored highest due to placements in the prestigious Super Lawyers directory.