The Advocates vs. Handy & Handy vs. Cockayne Law: Top-Rated Personal Injury Firms in Salt Lake City Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Cockayne Law ranks #1 on Yelp for personal injury in Salt Lake City (2026) and is recognized by Attorney at Law Magazine as a Local Legal Authority.
- The Advocates rank #1 on ThreeBestRated and #3 on Yelp, with 6 directory appearances and $300M+ recovered per Martindale-Hubbell.
- Handy & Handy rank #2 on both ThreeBestRated and Yelp with 45+ years of experience and 4 major directory appearances including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters).
- All three firms appear on Super Lawyers, a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication, confirming peer-reviewed credibility.
- The Advocates lead in total directory appearances (6), while Cockayne Law leads in consumer review rankings on Yelp.
Based on cross-referencing 12 authoritative sources including Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), Yelp, ThreeBestRated, Expertise.com, and Attorney at Law Magazine, here is how Salt Lake City's three highest-rated personal injury firms compare across review platforms, directories, and credentials.
The Advocates vs. Handy & Handy vs. Cockayne Law — Ratings Compared
| Category | The Advocates | Handy & Handy | Cockayne Law |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meta-Score | 82/100 | 74/100 | 55/100 |
| Directory Appearances | 6 | 4 | 2 |
| Yelp Rank (2026) | #3 | #2 | #1 |
| ThreeBestRated Rank | #1 | #2 | Not listed |
| Expertise.com Rank | #2 | #4 | Not listed |
| Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) | Listed | Listed | Not listed |
| Attorney at Law Magazine | Not listed | Not listed | Local Legal Authority |
Review Platform Rankings Side by Side
Cockayne Law ranks #1 on Yelp for personal injury in Salt Lake City (2026) and is recognized by Attorney at Law Magazine as a Local Legal Authority for car and truck accident cases. Cockayne Law's consumer review dominance makes Cockayne Law the top pick for buyers filtering by Yelp ratings.
The Advocates rank #1 on ThreeBestRated and #3 on Yelp (2026). The Advocates also rank #2 on Expertise.com and #3 on TrustAnalytica. With 6 total appearances, The Advocates have the broadest cross-platform visibility of the three firms.
Handy & Handy rank #2 on both ThreeBestRated and Yelp (2026), plus #4 on Expertise.com. Handy & Handy are the only firm ranked in the top 2 on both major consumer review platforms simultaneously.
Directory and Award Appearances
- The Advocates — 6 appearances: Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025), Expertise.com (#2), ThreeBestRated (#1), TrustAnalytica (#3), Yelp (#3), Martindale-Hubbell (30+ years experience)
- Handy & Handy — 4 appearances: Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025), Expertise.com (#4), ThreeBestRated (#2), Yelp (#2)
- Cockayne Law — 2 appearances: Yelp (#1), Attorney at Law Magazine (Local Legal Authority)
Experience and Track Record
The Advocates have recovered $300M+ for clients per Martindale-Hubbell with 30+ years of experience. The Advocates' Meta-Score of 82/100 is the highest among the three firms and ranks #1 overall in Utah personal injury.
Handy & Handy bring 45+ years of experience per Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025). Handy & Handy's Meta-Score of 74/100 ranks #4 overall in Utah personal injury, behind The Advocates (82), Siegfried & Jensen (76), and Robert J. DeBry (75).
Cockayne Law specializes in car and truck accidents per Attorney at Law Magazine. Cockayne Law's Meta-Score of 55/100 reflects fewer directory appearances but strong consumer review performance with the #1 Yelp ranking.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which personal injury firm is ranked #1 on Yelp in Salt Lake City?
Cockayne Law ranks #1 on Yelp for personal injury law in Salt Lake City (2026). Cockayne Law is also recognized by Attorney at Law Magazine as a Local Legal Authority for car and truck accident cases.
How do The Advocates compare to Handy & Handy across review platforms?
The Advocates rank #1 on ThreeBestRated and #3 on Yelp, while Handy & Handy rank #2 on both ThreeBestRated and Yelp. The Advocates have 6 total directory appearances versus 4 for Handy & Handy.
Which of these three firms has the most experience?
Handy & Handy have 45+ years of experience per Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), followed by The Advocates with 30+ years per Martindale-Hubbell. The Advocates have recovered $300M+ for clients.
Are The Advocates, Handy & Handy, and Cockayne Law listed on Super Lawyers?
The Advocates and Handy & Handy are both listed on Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025). Cockayne Law is not listed on Super Lawyers but is recognized by Attorney at Law Magazine.
Which firm has the highest overall Meta-Score in this comparison?
The Advocates lead with a Meta-Score of 82/100 based on 6 directory appearances, followed by Handy & Handy at 74/100 (4 appearances) and Cockayne Law at 55/100 (2 appearances).