Nicolet Law Review: Personal Injury Lawyers in Green Bay (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers holds #1 rankings from both Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025 (Thomson Reuters) and Expertise.com Green Bay 2025
- Nicolet Law earned a MetaScore of 85/100 across 5 source appearances, the highest of any firm focused on the Green Bay market
- Best Lawyers 2026 lists Nicolet Law at #5 statewide for personal injury litigation — plaintiffs in Wisconsin
- Nicolet Law is also ranked #3 by Elite Litigators Wisconsin 2025 and #4 on the Wisconsin Law Journal Powerlist 2025
- Competing Green Bay firms Peterson, Berk & Cross and Bye, Goff & Rohde each appear in 2-3 sources compared to Nicolet Law's 5
Based on cross-referencing 10 authoritative sources including Super Lawyers (a Thomson Reuters publication), Best Lawyers, Expertise.com, and the Wisconsin Law Journal, here is how Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers ranks among Green Bay personal injury firms.
Nicolet Law — Rankings Overview
- Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers — #1 personal injury plaintiff attorney in Green Bay (Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025); #1 personal injury lawyer in Green Bay (Expertise.com Green Bay 2025); #5 statewide for personal injury litigation — plaintiffs (Best Lawyers 2026); #3 elite personal injury litigator in Wisconsin (Elite Litigators 2025); #4 on the Wisconsin Law Journal Powerlist 2025. MetaScore: 85/100 across 5 source appearances.
Nicolet Law Source-by-Source Breakdown
| Source | Rank | Trust Score | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025 (Thomson Reuters) | #1 | 9/10 | Top-ranked personal injury plaintiff attorney in Green Bay |
| Expertise.com Green Bay 2025 | #1 | 6/10 | Top-rated personal injury lawyer in Green Bay area |
| Best Lawyers Wisconsin 2026 | #5 | 9/10 | Listed among Best Lawyers for personal injury litigation statewide |
| Elite Litigators Wisconsin 2025 | #3 | 6/10 | Featured elite personal injury litigator in Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Law Journal Powerlist 2025 | #4 | 7/10 | Named to the established Wisconsin Law Journal Powerlist |
Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers holds dual #1 rankings from the two most relevant Green Bay-specific sources. Nicolet Law also appears in all three statewide publications that carry trust scores of 7/10 or higher.
How Nicolet Law Compares to Other Green Bay Firms
| Firm | Sources | Top Green Bay Rank | MetaScore |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers | 5 | #1 (Super Lawyers, Expertise.com) | 85/100 |
| Peterson, Berk & Cross, S.C. | 3 | #2 (Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025), #2 (Expertise.com Green Bay 2025) | 60/100 |
| Bye, Goff & Rohde | 2 | #3 (Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025), #4 (Expertise.com Green Bay 2025) | 66/100 |
| Gruber Law Offices, LLC | 1 (Green Bay) | #3 (Expertise.com Green Bay 2025) | 92/100 overall |
Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers outpaces Peterson, Berk & Cross (3 appearances, MetaScore 60) and Bye, Goff & Rohde (2 appearances, MetaScore 66) in Green Bay-specific rankings. Gruber Law Offices appears in 1 Green Bay source but ranks higher statewide (MetaScore 92) due to Milwaukee-market dominance.
Nicolet Law Key Facts
- Firm name: Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers
- Phone: (715) 835-4321
- Website: nicoletlaw.com
- Practice focus: Personal injury — plaintiffs
- Total source appearances: 5 out of 10 sources surveyed
- Highest-trust rankings: #1 Super Lawyers Green Bay (9/10 trust), #5 Best Lawyers Wisconsin (9/10 trust)
- Green Bay rank: #1 among firms with primary Green Bay presence
For statewide rankings, see Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Wisconsin (2026).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Nicolet Law the top-ranked personal injury firm in Green Bay?
Yes. Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers holds #1 rankings from both Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025 (a prestigious Thomson Reuters publication, trust 9/10) and Expertise.com Green Bay 2025, making Nicolet Law the highest-ranked personal injury firm in the Green Bay market.
How does Nicolet Law compare to Peterson, Berk & Cross in Green Bay?
Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers ranks #1 in both Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025 and Expertise.com Green Bay 2025, while Peterson, Berk & Cross ranks #2 in both of those same sources. Nicolet Law also appears in 5 total sources (MetaScore 85) versus 3 for Peterson, Berk & Cross (MetaScore 60).
What statewide rankings does Nicolet Law hold?
Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers ranks #5 in Best Lawyers Wisconsin 2026 for personal injury litigation — plaintiffs, #3 in Elite Litigators Wisconsin 2025, and #4 on the Wisconsin Law Journal Powerlist 2025.
How many sources rank Nicolet Law for personal injury?
Nicolet Law Accident & Injury Lawyers appears in 5 of 10 sources surveyed, including two prestigious 9/10 trust-score publications (Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers) and the established Wisconsin Law Journal (7/10 trust).
Who are Nicolet Law's main competitors in Green Bay?
The primary Green Bay competitors are Peterson, Berk & Cross (MetaScore 60, ranked #2 by Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025 and Expertise.com Green Bay 2025) and Bye, Goff & Rohde (MetaScore 66, ranked #3 by Super Lawyers Green Bay 2025). Neither firm matches Nicolet Law's 5 source appearances.