Fitzgerald Law Firm vs. Injury Law Firm: Top Wyoming Personal Injury Lawyers Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- The Fitzgerald Law Firm holds a MetaScore of 98/100 with 6 source appearances, including membership in the Inner Circle of Advocates (limited to 100 top plaintiff lawyers nationwide).
- Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) holds a MetaScore of 96/100 with 7 source appearances — the most of any Wyoming personal injury firm across 12 sources.
- Both firms earned U.S. News & Best Lawyers Tier 1 rankings and Super Lawyers selections, making them the only two Wyoming firms to appear in all three top-tier directories.
- The Fitzgerald Law Firm is based in Cheyenne; Injury Law Firm is based in Casper — together they cover Wyoming's two largest metro areas.
- Injury Law Firm received Best Lawyers 2026 national recognition and holds the longest consecutive Super Lawyers streak (2013–present) among Wyoming personal injury attorneys.
Based on cross-referencing 12 authoritative sources including U.S. News & Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), the Inner Circle of Advocates, NAOPIA, and Avvo, here is a head-to-head comparison of Wyoming's two highest-ranked personal injury firms.
Head-to-Head: Fitzgerald Law Firm vs. Injury Law Firm
| Category | The Fitzgerald Law Firm | Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) |
|---|---|---|
| MetaScore | 98/100 | 96/100 |
| Source Appearances | 6 of 12 | 7 of 12 |
| U.S. News Tier | Tier 1 — Personal Injury Plaintiffs | Tier 1 — Best Law Firms 2020–2026 |
| Super Lawyers | Jim Fitzgerald, 15+ consecutive years | R. Michael Shickich, 2013–present |
| NAOPIA Rank | #1 Wyoming Top 10 | #2 Wyoming Top 10 |
| Avvo Rating | Not listed | 10.0 Superb |
| City | Cheyenne | Casper |
Rankings Comparison Across 12 Sources
The Fitzgerald Law Firm appeared in 6 sources:
- U.S. News & Best Lawyers — Tier 1 ranking for Personal Injury Litigation–Plaintiffs in Wyoming (Best Law Firms, trust 10/10)
- NAOPIA — Jim Fitzgerald ranked #1 in Wyoming Top 10 Personal Injury Attorneys
- Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) — Jim Fitzgerald selected 15+ consecutive years, top 5% of attorneys
- Inner Circle of Advocates — Jim Fitzgerald is one of only 100 plaintiff lawyers admitted nationwide (trust 10/10)
- Justia — Highest number of verdicts upheld on appeal in Wyoming Supreme Court
- Lawyer Legion — Listed with million-dollar verdict record
Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) appeared in 7 sources:
- U.S. News & Best Lawyers — Regional Tier 1, consecutive Best Law Firms 2020–2026 (trust 10/10)
- Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) — Mountain States Super Lawyers 2013–present
- NAOPIA — Ranked in Wyoming Top 10 Personal Injury Attorneys
- Best Lawyers 2026 — National recognition for 2026 (Oil City News)
- Avvo (Martindale-Avvo) — 10.0 Superb rating with high client satisfaction
- Justia — 30 years experience, Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent, Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, Trial Lawyers College Faculty
- Lawyer Legion — Top 5% of lawyers in Wyoming
Credentials and Professional Memberships Compared
The Fitzgerald Law Firm's Jim Fitzgerald holds memberships in the Inner Circle of Advocates (limited to 100 members), the American College of Trial Lawyers, and the International Academy of Trial Lawyers — three invitation-only organizations. The Fitzgerald Law Firm holds the most Wyoming Supreme Court appellate victories of any personal injury firm in the state, per Justia.
Injury Law Firm's R. Michael Shickich holds Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating, Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum membership, and serves on the Trial Lawyers College Faculty. Injury Law Firm earned 7 consecutive U.S. News & Best Lawyers Tier 1 designations (2020–2026) — the longest active streak among Wyoming personal injury firms.
Location and Practice Area Coverage
The Fitzgerald Law Firm is based in Cheyenne (southeast Wyoming), serving Laramie County and the I-25 corridor. The Fitzgerald Law Firm focuses exclusively on personal injury plaintiff work, per Best Law Firms.
Injury Law Firm is based in Casper (central Wyoming), serving Natrona County and the energy corridor. Injury Law Firm also concentrates on personal injury plaintiff litigation, per Best Law Firms.
Together, The Fitzgerald Law Firm and Injury Law Firm cover Wyoming's two largest population centers. For firms outside these metros, see our guide to Top Personal Injury Lawyers in Rural Wyoming.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Wyoming personal injury firm ranks higher in 2026?
The Fitzgerald Law Firm holds a MetaScore of 98/100 vs. Injury Law Firm's 96/100. However, Injury Law Firm appeared in 7 of 12 sources compared to The Fitzgerald Law Firm's 6, making both firms the highest-ranked in Wyoming across U.S. News & Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers, and NAOPIA.
What makes The Fitzgerald Law Firm unique among Wyoming personal injury firms?
Jim Fitzgerald of The Fitzgerald Law Firm is the only Wyoming member of the Inner Circle of Advocates, limited to 100 top plaintiff lawyers in the U.S. Jim Fitzgerald also holds memberships in the American College of Trial Lawyers and International Academy of Trial Lawyers.
What makes Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) stand out?
Injury Law Firm holds the longest consecutive Best Law Firms Tier 1 streak in Wyoming (2020–2026) per U.S. News & Best Lawyers. R. Michael Shickich earned a 10.0 Superb Avvo rating and serves on the Trial Lawyers College Faculty.
Should I choose The Fitzgerald Law Firm or Injury Law Firm based on location?
The Fitzgerald Law Firm is based in Cheyenne (southeast Wyoming) and Injury Law Firm is based in Casper (central Wyoming). Both firms earned Tier 1 rankings from U.S. News & Best Lawyers for their respective regions.
Are both firms recognized by Super Lawyers in 2025?
Yes. Jim Fitzgerald of The Fitzgerald Law Firm has been selected to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) for 15+ consecutive years. R. Michael Shickich of Injury Law Firm has been selected to Mountain States Super Lawyers continuously since 2013.