Top 5 Personal Injury Lawyers in Casper, Wyoming (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) holds a Tier 1 Best Law Firms ranking (U.S. News & Best Lawyers, 2020–2026) and Mountain States Super Lawyers selection since 2013.
- Gary L. Shockey PC is Wyoming's only Primerus member for plaintiffs' personal injury and carries a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating (2025).
- Murdock Law Firm LLC appears in both Best Law Firms (U.S. News) and Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) for Wyoming personal injury.
- Sandefer & Woolsey earned National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40 recognition (2012) and Super Lawyers selection for Ian Sandefer.
- Three of Casper's top 5 firms are recognized by NAOPIA's Wyoming Top 10 Personal Injury Attorneys list.
Based on cross-referencing 12 authoritative sources including Best Law Firms (U.S. News & Best Lawyers), Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), NAOPIA, and Primerus, here are the top-ranked personal injury lawyers in Casper, Wyoming for 2026.
Top 5 Personal Injury Lawyers in Casper — Ranked List
Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) — Regional Tier 1 ranking, Best Law Firms 2020–2026; Mountain States Super Lawyers 2013–present; #2 on NAOPIA Wyoming Top 10; Avvo 10.0 Superb rating; Best Lawyers 2026 national recognition; Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating; Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum member; Trial Lawyers College Faculty. 7 source appearances, 30 years experience. Phone: (307) 266-5297.
Gary L. Shockey PC — Wyoming's only Primerus member for plaintiffs' personal injury; Super Lawyers selection, top 5% of attorneys; listed in NAOPIA Wyoming Top 10; Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating (2025); Best Lawyers in America since 2001; Who's Who in American Law. 5 source appearances. Phone: (307) 266-5300.
Murdock Law Firm LLC — Listed among Best Law Firms in Wyoming for personal injury (U.S. News & Best Lawyers); J. Nicholas Murdock selected to Super Lawyers 2010–2012 and 2014–2020; listed in LawInfo directory, established 2008. 3 source appearances. Phone: (307) 235-5999.
Sandefer & Woolsey (Ian Sandefer) — Ian Sandefer selected to Mountain States Super Lawyers, top 5% of attorneys; NAOPIA Top 40 Under 40 by National Trial Lawyers (2012); Jamie Woolsey is a Trial Lawyers College graduate; million-dollar recoveries for clients (LawInfo). 4 source appearances. Phone: (307) 265-1000.
Macy Law Office PC — Listed among Casper personal injury attorneys in Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters) and Lawyer Legion Wyoming directory. 2 source appearances.
Casper Firms With National Recognition
Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) earned Best Lawyers 2026 national recognition and has held a Tier 1 Best Law Firms ranking for seven consecutive years (2020–2026). Gary L. Shockey PC is the only Wyoming firm in Primerus, an international network requiring AV Preeminent ratings and peer vetting. Murdock Law Firm LLC is one of only a handful of Casper firms listed in both Best Law Firms (U.S. News) and Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters).
Multi-Office Firms Serving Casper
Several firms based outside Casper maintain offices or active caseloads in the area. The Spence Law Firm (Jackson, WY) has offices in Casper and has recovered over $1 billion in verdicts and settlements (Lawyer Legion, Justia). Metier Law Firm operates Casper, Cheyenne, and Gillette offices with over 40 years of experience and Board Certification in truck accident litigation (Justia). Burg Simpson Eldredge Hersh & Jardine, a U.S. News Top Law Firm with 40 Best Lawyers in America designations, serves Wyoming from a Cody office managed by Colin M. Simpson (Avvo 10.0 rating).
For statewide rankings, see our Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Wyoming (2026) or the Cheyenne-specific rankings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the highest-rated personal injury lawyer in Casper, Wyoming?
Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) holds the most recognitions among Casper firms, including a Tier 1 Best Law Firms ranking (U.S. News & Best Lawyers, 2020–2026), Mountain States Super Lawyers selection since 2013, and an Avvo 10.0 Superb rating.
Which Casper personal injury firms appear in Best Law Firms (U.S. News)?
Injury Law Firm (R. Michael Shickich) and Murdock Law Firm LLC are both listed in Best Law Firms (U.S. News & Best Lawyers) for personal injury in Wyoming, with Injury Law Firm holding a Tier 1 regional ranking.
Are there nationally recognized personal injury trial lawyers in Casper?
Gary L. Shockey PC is Wyoming's only Primerus member for plaintiffs' personal injury, requiring AV Preeminent peer ratings. Injury Law Firm's R. Michael Shickich is a Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum member and Trial Lawyers College Faculty.
Which Casper injury lawyers are on the Super Lawyers list?
According to Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, 2025), R. Michael Shickich (Injury Law Firm), Gary L. Shockey (Gary L. Shockey PC), J. Nicholas Murdock (Murdock Law Firm), and Ian Sandefer (Sandefer & Woolsey) are all selected to the Wyoming Super Lawyers list for personal injury.
Do any large multi-office firms handle personal injury cases in Casper?
The Spence Law Firm (over $1 billion in verdicts, Lawyer Legion) and Metier Law Firm (Board Certified in truck accident litigation, Justia) both maintain Casper offices alongside their other Wyoming locations.