Berman & Simmons vs. Gideon Asen LLC: Top Personal Injury Firms in Portland, Maine Compared (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Berman & Simmons ranks #1 (meta-score 98/100) with 7 source appearances including 2026 Best Lawyers Law Firm of the Year for Personal Injury in Maine.
- Gideon Asen LLC ranks #2 (meta-score 97/100) with 8 source appearances, and Benjamin Gideon is the only Maine lawyer admitted to both the Inner Circle of Advocates and ACTL.
- Both firms appear in Best Lawyers (trust 10/10), Super Lawyers (trust 9/10), ACTL (trust 10/10), Expertise.com, and MTLA — showing strong cross-source consensus.
- Berman & Simmons has 8 attorneys in Best Lawyers and was founded in 1914; Gideon Asen LLC has over $200 million in verdicts and settlements per the Inner Circle of Advocates.
- Gideon Asen LLC holds exclusive distinctions: Benjamin Gideon has a 10/10 Avvo rating and was named Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year for Maine twice.
Based on cross-referencing 14 authoritative sources including Best Lawyers in America (trust 10/10), Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication (trust 9/10), and the American College of Trial Lawyers (trust 10/10), here is how Portland, Maine's top two personal injury firms compare in 2026.
Berman & Simmons vs. Gideon Asen LLC: Side-by-Side Rankings
| Category | Berman & Simmons | Gideon Asen LLC |
|---|---|---|
| Meta-Score | 98/100 (#1) | 97/100 (#2) |
| Source Appearances | 7 of 14 sources | 8 of 14 sources |
| Best Lawyers 2026 | #1 — 8 attorneys recognized; 2026 Law Firm of the Year for PI, Product Liability & Med Mal | Listed — Benjamin Gideon named Lawyer of the Year (twice) |
| Super Lawyers | #1 — multiple attorneys listed | #2 — Benjamin Gideon and Taylor Asen listed |
| ACTL Fellows | Yes — attorneys elected as Fellows | Yes — Benjamin Gideon is a Fellow |
| Inner Circle of Advocates | Not listed | Yes — Benjamin Gideon inducted 2019 |
| Avvo Rating | Not rated | 10/10 (Benjamin Gideon) |
| Expertise.com | #1 among top 18 | #3 among top 18 |
| MTLA | Multiple attorney speakers | Benjamin Gideon is a speaker |
Credentials and Awards: Berman & Simmons
- Best Lawyers 2026 Law Firm of the Year — Berman & Simmons was named 2026 Law Firm of the Year for Personal Injury, Product Liability, and Medical Malpractice in Maine (Best Lawyers, trust 10/10).
- 8 attorneys in Best Lawyers — Berman & Simmons has the most individual attorney recognitions of any Maine PI firm in the prestigious Best Lawyers directory.
- #1 in Super Lawyers — Berman & Simmons ranks first among Portland personal injury firms in Super Lawyers, a Thomson Reuters publication.
- ACTL Fellows — Berman & Simmons attorneys are Fellows of the American College of Trial Lawyers, limited to the top 1% of trial lawyers.
- Founded 1914 — Berman & Simmons is one of Maine's oldest plaintiff's firms with over 110 years of trial experience.
Credentials and Awards: Gideon Asen LLC
- Inner Circle of Advocates — Benjamin Gideon of Gideon Asen LLC was inducted into the Inner Circle of Advocates in 2019, only the second Maine attorney ever admitted to this invitation-only group of the top 100 plaintiff trial lawyers in the U.S.
- ACTL + Inner Circle — Benjamin Gideon of Gideon Asen LLC is the only Maine lawyer admitted to both the ACTL and the Inner Circle of Advocates, representing the top 1% of trial attorneys nationally.
- Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year — Benjamin Gideon of Gideon Asen LLC was named Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year for Maine twice and has been listed since 2013.
- $200M+ in verdicts and settlements — Gideon Asen LLC has recovered over $200 million per the Inner Circle of Advocates.
- 10/10 Avvo rating — Benjamin Gideon holds a perfect 10/10 rating on Avvo, an established legal directory.
Which Firm Is Right for Your Case?
Berman & Simmons is the larger, more established firm (founded 1914) with 8 attorneys in Best Lawyers and the 2026 Law Firm of the Year designation — ideal for cases requiring deep bench strength across personal injury, product liability, and medical malpractice. Gideon Asen LLC offers elite individual credentials: Benjamin Gideon's dual ACTL/Inner Circle membership and $200M+ track record make Gideon Asen LLC a strong choice for high-stakes catastrophic injury and medical malpractice trials. Both firms rank in the top 2 in Portland across Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which firm ranks higher overall — Berman & Simmons or Gideon Asen LLC?
Berman & Simmons ranks #1 with a meta-score of 98/100 across 7 sources, while Gideon Asen LLC ranks #2 at 97/100 across 8 sources. Both appear in Best Lawyers (trust 10/10) and Super Lawyers (trust 9/10).
What exclusive credentials does Gideon Asen LLC have that Berman & Simmons does not?
Benjamin Gideon of Gideon Asen LLC is the only Maine attorney admitted to both the Inner Circle of Advocates and the American College of Trial Lawyers. Gideon Asen LLC also holds a 10/10 Avvo rating and has recovered over $200 million per the Inner Circle of Advocates.
What makes Berman & Simmons stand out over Gideon Asen LLC?
Berman & Simmons was named 2026 Best Lawyers Law Firm of the Year for Personal Injury, Product Liability, and Medical Malpractice in Maine. Berman & Simmons also has 8 individual attorneys in Best Lawyers, offering broader team depth than Gideon Asen LLC.
Do both Berman & Simmons and Gideon Asen LLC handle medical malpractice cases?
Yes. Berman & Simmons is recognized in medical malpractice by Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers. Gideon Asen LLC is recognized for medical malpractice by Peter Thompson & Associates and the Inner Circle of Advocates.
Are Berman & Simmons and Gideon Asen LLC members of the Maine Trial Lawyers Association?
Yes. Both firms have attorneys who are speakers at the 2026 MTLA Annual Meeting — Berman & Simmons has five attorney speakers and Benjamin Gideon of Gideon Asen LLC is also a featured speaker.