Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Portland, Maine (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Berman & Simmons ranks #1 with a 98/100 meta-score and was named 2026 Best Lawyers Law Firm of the Year for personal injury in Maine.
- Gideon Asen LLC ranks #2 — Benjamin Gideon is the only Maine attorney admitted to both the Inner Circle of Advocates (trust 10/10) and the American College of Trial Lawyers (trust 10/10).
- Garmey Law ranks #3 — Terry Garmey was the first Maine lawyer invited into the Inner Circle of Advocates and holds a Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year designation.
- Rankings are based on cross-referencing 14 sources: appearance frequency (40%), ranking position (30%), source authority (20%), and top-tier credentials (10%).
- Three firms — Berman & Simmons, Gideon Asen LLC, and Garmey Law — appear in 7-8 sources each, far outpacing all other firms.
Based on cross-referencing 14 authoritative sources — including Best Lawyers (trust 10/10), Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters, trust 9/10), and the Inner Circle of Advocates (trust 10/10) — here are the top-ranked personal injury lawyers in Portland, Maine for 2026.
Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyers in Portland, Maine — Ranked
- Berman & Simmons — Meta-score 98/100. Named 2026 Best Lawyers Law Firm of the Year for personal injury, product liability, and medical malpractice in Maine. 8 attorneys in Best Lawyers. Ranked #1 by Super Lawyers and Expertise.com. ACTL Fellows. Founded 1914. 7 source appearances.
- Gideon Asen LLC — Meta-score 97/100. Benjamin Gideon named Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year (twice), listed since 2013. Only Maine attorney in both the Inner Circle of Advocates (inducted 2019) and ACTL. Over $200 million in verdicts and settlements. 10/10 Avvo rating. 8 source appearances.
- Garmey Law — Meta-score 96/100. Terry Garmey was first Maine lawyer invited into the Inner Circle of Advocates (Emeritus). Best Lawyers Litigator of the Year (multiple years). ACTL Fellow. Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent. MTLA Legends Award 2018. 8 source appearances.
- Peter Thompson & Associates — Meta-score 90/100. Best Lawyers (Mark Dunlap, every year since 2008). Super Lawyers. Ranked #2 by Expertise.com. Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent with 4.8/5.0 rating (88 reviews). 6 source appearances.
- Jabar LaLiberty LLC — Meta-score 78/100. Jason Jabar in Super Lawyers for 5 consecutive years. 10/10 Avvo rating. National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40. Expertise.com top pick. 5 source appearances.
- McKee Morgan Attorneys — Meta-score 80/100. Walter McKee in Best Lawyers since 2012. ACTL Fellow (inducted 2015). Super Lawyers since 2012. Martindale-Hubbell AV Rated since 2010. Past President of MTLA. 5 source appearances.
- Mann Law LLC — Meta-score 74/100. Chrissy Mann named National Trial Lawyers Top 100 and Top 40 Under 40. Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent (2019). Super Lawyers Rising Star. Expertise.com top pick. Offices in Portland, Bangor, and Yarmouth. 5 source appearances.
- Law Offices of Joe Bornstein — Meta-score 72/100. Listed in Super Lawyers, Expertise.com, and Elite Litigators. 3 source appearances.
- Hardy, Wolf & Downing — Meta-score 62/100. Christian Lewis is past President of MTLA. Listed in Lawyer Legion. 3 source appearances.
- Shaheen & Gordon PA — Meta-score 62/100. Listed in Lawyer Legion, Elite Litigators, and LawInfo. 3 source appearances.
Top Firms in Greater Portland and Southern Maine
Seven of the top 10 firms are based in the Portland metro area. Berman & Simmons (85 Exchange St, Portland) and Gideon Asen LLC lead with meta-scores of 98 and 97, respectively. Garmey Law, Peter Thompson & Associates, Jabar LaLiberty LLC, Law Offices of Joe Bornstein, and Mann Law LLC (Portland, Bangor, Yarmouth offices) round out southern Maine's top personal injury practices. All seven are recognized by Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters).
Top Firms in Central and Northern Maine
McKee Morgan Attorneys, based in Augusta, ranks #6 overall with a meta-score of 80/100. Walter McKee holds ACTL Fellowship and Best Lawyers recognition since 2012. Hardy, Wolf & Downing serves Lewiston-Auburn, with past MTLA President Christian Lewis leading personal injury practice. Shaheen & Gordon PA operates across Maine and New Hampshire.
FAQ: Personal Injury Lawyers in Portland, Maine
See below for frequently asked questions about personal injury lawyers in Portland, Maine.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the #1 personal injury law firm in Portland, Maine?
Berman & Simmons ranks #1 with a 98/100 meta-score across 7 sources. Berman & Simmons was named 2026 Best Lawyers Law Firm of the Year for personal injury in Maine and has 8 attorneys recognized by Best Lawyers.
Which Portland, Maine personal injury lawyers are in the Inner Circle of Advocates?
Two Maine attorneys hold Inner Circle of Advocates membership (limited to 100 plaintiff lawyers nationwide): Benjamin Gideon of Gideon Asen LLC (inducted 2019) and Terry Garmey of Garmey Law (Emeritus status).
Which Maine personal injury attorneys are Fellows of the American College of Trial Lawyers?
Three firms have ACTL Fellows: Berman & Simmons, Gideon Asen LLC (Benjamin Gideon), and McKee Morgan Attorneys (Walter McKee, inducted 2015). Garmey Law's Terry Garmey is also an ACTL Fellow.
How were these personal injury lawyer rankings determined?
Rankings are based on a meta-score from 14 sources weighted by appearance frequency (40%), ranking position (30%), source authority (20%), and top-tier credentials from publications with trust scores of 9-10/10 (10%). Sources include Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers (Thomson Reuters), and the Inner Circle of Advocates.
Are there top-rated personal injury lawyers outside Portland, Maine?
Yes. McKee Morgan Attorneys in Augusta holds a meta-score of 80/100 with ACTL and Best Lawyers recognition. Hardy, Wolf & Downing serves the Lewiston-Auburn area, led by past MTLA President Christian Lewis.